Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire
  • omnibus

Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Chowdhry, BAR Comments Editor
30 Jan 2019
Letters from Our Readers
Letters from Our Readers

This week readers decided to comment on the 2020 Democratic Party primary, the US role in the recent Congolese presidential election, and the correct understanding of the role sexuality in shaping politics. The most substantive comments came in for “Bernie Sanders vs Kamala the Jailer and Her Corporate Backers,” “Anti-Imperialist Dilemma: What If the US Is “Right” About the Election in the Congo,” and “BAR Book Forum: Amber Musser’s Sexual Excess.”

In “Bernie Sanders vs Kamala the Jailer and Her Corporate Backers” Glen Fordargues that the best possible scenario for the 2020 election is for Bernie Sanders to surge in the primaries and be denied the nomination, pushing millions of leftish Democrats to leave the party.

Charles Shapiro writes:

“Cede the government to Donald Trump and those that will push the agenda way farther from where you want it to be? Like Trump? Want 4 more years of him? Then go right on and vote your conscience. The world, right now, would be a better place if you hadn't by settling for Clinton.”

Marc Abian responds:

“My Great-Great-Grandma was born a slave in 1860. She was free before she turned five because one third of the country ‘threw their vote away’ and voted for a funny looking third party candidate with pretty speeches and no chance to be anything but a spoiler. ‘Everyone’ votes for what they really want. Affluent people often lie on the internet about what they really want.”

In “Anti-Imperialist Dilemma: What If the US Is “Right” About the Election in the Congo” Ann Garrisonargues for the legitimacy of Martin Fayulu as the winner of the Congolese presidential election despite the fact that the US opposed outgoing President Kabila’s attempt to deny Fayulu his mandate.

Joe Kelly writes:

"To be honest Ann Garrison's article is a surprising misstep for Black Agenda Report. The question posed, in the first place, shows Garrison's misdirection. Frankly, it doesn't matter whether the US has for once taken the correct line or not. It is simply a problem that the US is in the wider region meddling -- and Garrison overlooks that. Is the election result legit despite US endorsement of the winner? Who the hell can really know, especially on this side of the Atlantic? What we do know is that this is an election that occurred in the midst of a robust US imperial presence. And that shouldn't be taken as an inconsiderable factor, especially for a country that has the deep footprint of US over-lordship in its politics going back to the 1960s. Remember that farcical Rumble in the Jungle? Not one of Ali's best moments, politically-speaking. Don't let misguided questions be your worst moment too as a radical black publication."

Anne Garrison responds:

“A number of people wrote to me to object to my last essay and particularly the headline “Anti-imperialist Dilemma: ‘What If the US Is 'Right' About the Election in DR Congo?’ The parentheses around ‘right’ were meant to indicate that US foreign policy is never based on principle, but that it might occasionally—very occasionally—happen to coincide with the will of the people. (In this case, until the day after my piece was published. I wrote that in response to people who were angrily, and understandably, insisting that if the US favored Martin Fayulu, they opposed him. Eminent Congolese author Patrick Mbeko had written that there are always fierce imperial motivations at work in DRC because of its vast geostrategic resources, but that honoring the Congolese people’s electoral choice was most important, no matter what the US or any other imperial powers said or did. (Please see further discussion in this week's interview with Maurice Carney).”

In “BAR Book Forum: Amber Musser’s Sexual Excess” Roberto Sirvent interviews the author on the framing power of sexuality as an ideology of respectability and control.

Djata Bumpus writes

“Your recent interview in the ‘Book Forum,’ by Roberto Sirvent of Amber Musser about her new book titled ‘Sensual Excess,’ at least to me, betrays the usual honest and thoughtful commentary that appears in BAR.

“Right from the start, just like the super-racist Hillary Clinton does when saying her ‘women and minorities’ drivel, Amber Musser points to ‘black people, immigrants, LGBT people.’ So,who are LGBT people? Apparently, they are not either African American or ‘immigrants’ (as if all immigrants have the same national origin). Does the moniker LGBT represent a new species?

“As far as oppression goes in a socially-stratified civilization such as ours, one can belong to an oppressor group and an oppressed one, simultaneously. A good example is the Clarence Thomas/Anita Hill debacle. Thomas was oppressed as Hill is for being Black. However, as a male, he oppresses females, because of Male Supremacy. Likewise, anyone who calls himself or herself ‘white’ does so, mean-spiritedly, as opposed to ‘European American,’ in order to be part of an artificial ‘majority’ group. Moreover, since LGBT people separate themselves from African Americans and others, then they are no less a ‘white supremacist movement’ than the Zionists pf the USA and Israel are.

“Finally, I embrace Freud's definition of identity: an emotional tie. Language is thought! Have you ever said to yourself, ‘I can't think of a word for it.?’ Furthermore, we must identify ourselves through our connection between generations, especially family ties, of cultural and historical camaraderie through both life's struggles and victories. That will give each generation a thoughtful and meaningful way to look at life NOT this moronism about identifying yourself through your genitals or the sexual impulses that are triggered through that genitalia: a thoughtless and meaningless trajectory will be the only product of that type of thinking. The great Fanon insisted, ‘Each generation must out of relative obscurity discover its mission, fulfill it or betray it.’ BAR must stay the course!”

Debating a correct understanding of race and other social oppressions is a key part of the struggle for ideological clarity in our movements. Looking forward to more debate in next week’s letters.

Jahan Choudhry is Comments Editor for Black Agenda Report. He is an organizer with the Saturday Free School based in Philadelphia, PA.

Comments

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles. Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
21 April 2021
This week pro-Zionist censorship and police brutality were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
by Jahan Choudhry, Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
07 April 2021
In "On Anarchism and Black Revolution" Peter James Hudson examines the historical roots of critiques of anarchism a
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
31 March 2021
This week the U.S. state’s propaganda and the Black elite were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
10 March 2021
This week Pan Africanism and the Black Panther Party were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
03 March 2021
This week the blackout in Texas, the recent film on Fred Hampton, and Democracy Now’s international coverage were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
24 February 2021
This week you discussed the struggle against the dollar and neocolonialism.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
17 February 2021
This week color-blindness on the left and the Black Misleadership Class were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
10 February 2021
This week you discussed the multilayer crisis facing American people.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
03 February 2021
The federal government’s stimulus payments and the role of black police officers were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
27 January 2021
This week our readers talked about the weakness of the U.S. left, the storming of the Capitol, and the crisis of U.S. imperialism.

More Stories


  • Black Alliance For Peace
    BAP Condemns the Zionist Brutalization and Detainment of Chris Smalls, Emblematic of the White Supremacy at the Core of Zionism
    06 Aug 2025
    The arrest and assault of Chris Smalls is about more than the repression of any effort to subvert the genocidal blockade on Gaza; it exposes Israel’s attempt to sever Black and Palestinian solidarity…
  • Vijay Prashad
    Unilateral and Illegal Sanctions – Mainly by the United States – Kill Half a Million Civilians Per Year: The Thirty-First Newsletter (2025)
    06 Aug 2025
    A study in The Lancet estimates that unilateral sanctions have caused as much death as wars, with an estimated half a million deaths per year.
  • Pindiga Ambedkar , Arnold August
    Were Canadian Elections Existential in the Context of US-Canada Tensions? (Part 2)
    06 Aug 2025
    Interview with Arnold August, writer, political commentator, and analyst of the North American continent, on the political situation in Canada and its relationship to the US.
  • Khaled Barakat
    Saudi Arabia and France are Leading a ‘Political Genocide’
    06 Aug 2025
    The New York Declaration doesn't merely betray Palestine. It weaponizes the language of statehood to formalize the suppression of a people's right to exist without colonial rule.
  • Nicholas Mwangi
    Youth-led anti-corruption movement surges in The Gambia
    06 Aug 2025
    Gambians from all walks of life – led by the youth-driven GALA movement mobilized across the country on July 23 in an anti-corruption protest as momentum for change grows.
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us