Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Another Black Face on MSNBC: Good News For Joy Ann Reid, Not So Much For The Rest of Us
Bruce Dixon
26 Feb 2025
🖨️ Print Article
Joy Ann Reid

This piece was originally printed in BAR in 2014.

If Fox News is the Republican ministry of TV propaganda, MSNBC is the mouthpiece of the White House and corporate Democrats. The last real journalist in an MSNBC host spot was Phil Donahue, fired for letting antiwar lefties on the air once in a while. MSNBC must have a lot of confidence that their new host, Joy-Ann Reid, will carry their water and leverage her black face to carry their message to us instead of the other way around.

“A lot has changed in fifty years, and a lot hasn't. A few things have gotten better and many others have gotten worse.”

Back in 1962, when I was twelve years old growing up on the south side of Chicago, and a black face showed up on TV, I remember my mother going to one of the windows of our apartment and shouting to the neighbors whose windows faced us less than 20 feet away. "Quick, there's one of us on channel 2!" To be fair, sometimes she used the phone for this, too, and recalls receiving these calls as well as seeing them made.

That's really how it was back in the day, half a century ago. We knew we were black, we knew we were here, we knew we mattered somehow, but in the world of corporate-owned television, we had been rendered all but invisible, made to pretty much disappear.

There really were not a lot of black faces on the tube at all, so seeing one was a kind of affirmation, a tangible proof, in a strange way, almost as if the world brought to us by corporate-owned broadcasting was more real than our own lives, that we really did exist, that we really did matter somehow in the scheme of things. We were looking for our own faces, our own stories, our own voices in corporate media and public life, and since we'd never even been able to pretend to have these things before, they assumed enormous importance for us that is hard to understand in today's world.

A lot has changed in fifty years, and a lot hasn't. A few things have gotten better, and many others have gotten worse. Black unemployment is still double white unemployment, and black wealth remains a tiny fraction of white wealth. Gentrification is still the only model of urban economic development on offer, and the number of black faces in prisons and jails has grown enormously since 1963, the last year whites were a majority in US prisons and jails.

But black voter registration has never been higher, and there have never been more black elected and appointed officials on every level, from mayors to sheriffs to legislators and generals and even a president. So things are indeed getting better, at least for some of us. Things are certainly looking up for the family and friends of Joy Ann Reid, who's getting her own slot in the MSNBC TV daily lineup alongside Al Sharpton, Rachel Maddow, weekender Melissa Harris-Perry and the rest of that crew.

Just as Fox News is the propaganda arm of the Republican party, the White House and corporate Democrats, as if any other kind really matters, have MSNBC on lockdown. You don't earn a daily slot on either side of corporate media if you're not a consistent and effective shill for corporate interests – for the privatization of public education, for US imperial interventions, and war crimes in Africa, South Asia, and the Americas, for fracking, for unfettered police spying, and for only attacking the bad things the other party does. That's Joy Ann Reid to a T, and that's how you earn those slots at Fox or MSNBC, and that's how you keep them.

The last real journalist with a daily MSNBC slot was Phil Donahue, who was fired for giving air time to lefty criticisms of the invasion of Iraq. The big boys at Comcast, which owns MSNBC, must have a lot of confidence in Joy Ann Reid to use her blackface to effectively represent their interests.

A half-century ago, we imagined that if there were more black faces in more high places, they'd represent our interests—silly us. We really didn't see this coming.

For Black Agenda Radio, I'm Bruce Dixon. Find us on the web at www.blackagendareport.com.

The late Bruce A. Dixon was managing editor at Black Agenda Report and a state committee member of the Georgia Green Party. 

Corporate Media
misleaders
propaganda

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
Truth, Lies and an Assassination Attempt
29 April 2026
The impetus to question official narratives is quite logical, given the U.S.
Alan MacLeod
From Dunks to Drones: The NBA Has an Israel Problem
22 April 2026
Behind the glamour of the NBA playoffs lies a coordinated effort by the league, its owners, and star players to promote the zionist entity.&nbs
Julia Kassem
‘Israel’: The Glue That Pieces Together the Maxwell-Epstein Saga
18 February 2026
Julia Kassem argues the Maxwell–Epstein saga is best understood through the lens of Israeli intelligence networks, tracing a continuity of espi
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
War Propaganda, State Controlled Media, and the End of African Stream
25 June 2025
African Stream's Pan-African, anti-imperialist journalistic perspectives made it the target of a state
Trump and Harris
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
Corruption, Lies, Biden's Health and Trump's Victory
14 May 2025
The same corporate media talking heads who told us to ignore Biden’s failing health are now cashing in
Briahna Joy Gray
Why Did MSNBC Cancel Joy Reid?
12 March 2025
Some speculated that racism explains the firing of the liberal anchor. But MSNBC doesn't have a problem with Black hosts.
sputnik
Jamarl Thomas
The Life and Times of a "Russian Propagandist"
30 October 2024
RT and Sputnik weren’t closed for getting it wrong.
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
New York Times Attacks “Peace-peddling” Jill Stein as the Presidential Race Comes Down to the Wire
23 October 2024
The New York Times scapegoats Green Party presidential candidate Dr.
Noah Shachtman
The Secretive Alliance Between the New York Post and Eric Adams
02 October 2024
Rupert Murdoch’s paper helped elect Adams and hasn’t quite given up on him yet.
Raymond Nat Turner, BAR poet-in-residence
If grits ain’t groceries and Mona Lisa was a man, was Dr. Goebbels good?
18 September 2024
“The American fascists are most easily recogni

More Stories


  • US Post-9/11 Wars Caused 4.5 million Deaths, Displaced 38-60 Million People, Study Shows
    Ben Norton
    US Post-9/11 Wars Caused 4.5 million Deaths, Displaced 38-60 Million People, Study Shows
    24 May 2023
    Wars the US waged in Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, Yemen, and Pakistan following September 11, 2001 caused at least 4.5 million deaths and displaced 38 to 60 million people, with 7.6 million children…
  • Abolish the GILEE Program and Stop Cop City: A Statement From the Black Alliance for Peace Atlanta Citywide Alliance
    Black Alliance for Peace Atlanta City-Wide Alliance
    Abolish the GILEE Program and Stop Cop City: A Statement From the Black Alliance for Peace Atlanta Citywide Alliance
    24 May 2023
    The purpose of U.S. law enforcement training in Israel is to learn the violent tactics used against Palestinians and bring them back to this country. 
  • Rising Tensions in Colombian Government Peace Talks with the ELN
    Peoples Dispatch
    Rising Tensions in Colombian Government Peace Talks with the ELN
    24 May 2023
    Colombia's president Gustavo Petro met with Afro-descendant, Indigenous and peasant communities affected by illicit crops and guerrilla and paramilitary groups in Colombia. Talks between the…
  • Sudan: The Left Welcomes Ceasefire, Calls for Involvement of Civil Society, Regional Institutions
    Pavan Kulkarni
    Sudan: The Left Welcomes Ceasefire, Calls for Involvement of Civil Society, Regional Institutions
    24 May 2023
    The Sudanese Communist Party has welcomed the ceasefire between the army and the Rapid Support Forces but has warned against monopolization of the peace process by US and Saudi Arabia. It has called…
  • Black Agenda Radio May 19, 2023
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Black Agenda Radio May 19, 2023
    19 May 2023
    How bail reform has been undermined by legislators in New York State and around the country, and New York City mayor Eric Adams’ response to the killing of Jordan Neely. But first we learn about the…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us