Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire
  • omnibus

Haiti and a Long History of Assault
Lautaro Rivara
28 Oct 2020
Haiti and a Long History of Assault
Haiti and a Long History of Assault

For fifteen years Latin American nations collaborated in the military occupation of Haiti, but have yet to apologize for their crimes.

“A domestic political conflict was used as the pretext for the 2004 coup.”

Haiti’s Struggle with Their Latin American Neighbors

Thirteen United Nations peacekeeping missions are underway in various countries in Africa, Asia and the Middle East. Haiti has been the epicenter of the UN peacekeeping missions in Latin America and the Caribbean; there have been eight UN missions since the International Civilian Mission in Haiti (MICIVIH) was deployed in Haiti in 1993. On October 15, 2019, the UN finally ended its 15-year-long peacekeeping mission in Haiti that began in 2004, leaving behind a “mixed legacy.”

The most dramatic intervention took place in 2004, after the coup d’état against the democratically elected President Jean-Bertrand Aristide. Camille Chalmers, executive director of the Haitian Platform to Advocate Alternative Development, a civil society organization network, said in 2019 that a domestic political conflict was used as the pretext. 

The coup was carried out by ex-military personnel whose forces had been dissolved by Aristide in 1995. Backed by the United States, Canada and France, the army of the coup entered from the Dominican Republic and marched to Port-au-Prince.

After Aristide’s forced exile, interim President Boniface Alexandre requested the first deployment of a Multinational Interim Force. 

Composed of Canadian, French, U.S. and Chilean soldiers, this force would be the seed of the future United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH). Both the request and the occupation itself contravened Haiti’s 1987 Constitution; only the National Assembly has the power to make these decisions, but it was circumvented by Alexandre.

The UN’s Arguments: ‘Stabilization’ and ‘Humanitarian Interventionism’

Since the creation of MINUSTAH, a series of euphemisms have emerged to justify the occupation, such as ‘suspension of sovereignty,’ ‘humanitarian interventionism,’ and ‘pacification.’ 

In practice, pacification implied an exercise of selective political repression, the perpetration of various sexual crimes, and the propagation of a cholera epidemic from a MINUSTAH base that claimed 10,000 lives and infected more than 800,000 people. This was belatedly acknowledged by the then UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, who also apologized for the UN’s response to the cholera outbreak.

The creation of MINUSTAH took place in the context of the international agenda being shaped by the rhetoric of ‘security’ and ‘terrorism.’ Since the fall of the Soviet Union and the decline of the Non-Aligned Movement, the Security Council developed an increasingly discretionary character and the powers of the UN General Assembly were reduced. 

In turn, Chapter VI of the UN Charter, which refers to the peaceful settlement of disputes, was increasingly displaced by Chapter VII, which provides for the imposition of so-called “peace enforcement” and the deployment of the UN’s Blue Helmets, as the peacekeepers are known.

On the other hand, a new international legal paradigm began to impose itself: that of “humanitarian interventionism” and the “responsibility to protect,” also known as R2P. As Leyla Carrillo Ramírez, a Cuban jurist and specialist in international relations, writes in her book Metáforas de la Intervención, these are forms of “coercive foreign intervention.” 

These, Ramírez says, contradict the principles of sovereignty and self-determination of nations, even when they are protected by the real or alleged violation of the human rights of local populations.

Brazil: The ‘Principle of Non-Indifference’ and Geopolitical Aspirations

In 2004, Brazil took charge of the military command of MINUSTAH, in addition to being the country that provided the largest military contingent: 1,670 soldiers at the beginning of the mission.

The guiding principle of Brazilian diplomacy was that of ‘non-indifference,’ a sort of local variation of R2P. This edge of the South American giant’s foreign policy was accompanied by its willingness to influence international policy in line with its character as an emerging country, a dynamic member of BRICS and a sub-regional power.

Brazil led the policy of population control in working-class neighborhoods such as Bel Air and Cité Soleil in Haiti. In Cité Soleil, an armed intervention took place in 2007 that killed at least 27 civilians and left 30 wounded, according to the testimonies of the inhabitants and the complaint filed with the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (CIDH). 

However, according to a special dossier of the IgarapéInstitute and the Brazilian Peace Operations Joint Training Center, the official self-evaluation would be extremely laudable, qualifying the Brazilian performance in Haiti as a “military epic.”

The other reason for Brazilian participation had to do with the direct negotiations established between the Brazilian, French and U.S. governments. 

According to Ricardo Seitenfus, former special representative of the Organization of American States in Haiti, former U.S. President George W. Bush had promised the Brazilian government a permanent seat on the UN Security Council in exchange for taking over MINUSTAH.

Argentina and the Relegitimization of the Armed Forces

As in the entire Southern Cone, the Argentine Armed Forces were involved in state terrorism and the coordinated repression of Operation Condor in the mid-1970s. But only in Argentina would the military reach such a level of discredit, brought about by factors such as the defeat in the Malvinas War and the emergence of a powerful human rights movement.

Argentina’s participation in the UN missions was due to an attempt to re-function and re-legitimize the forces in a democratic context, according to Argentina’s Presence in Haiti, a book by authors affiliated with the National University of Quilmes and Argentina’s Ministry of Defense. 

In fact, a working document of the Frente de Todos, a coalition of political parties in Argentina, presented in October 2019 referred, in its section on foreign policy, to the need to strengthen Argentina’s presence in peace missions, and referred to the country’s experience of participating in MINUSTAH.

Argentina’s Presence in Haiti  highlights the enormous deficits in the training of the troops sent to Haiti. These include the incompatibility between military training and the assumption of police tasks, the complete lack of knowledge about local reality and culture, and the practical absence of training with a gender perspective. 

This is particularly relevant in the case of troops who served where there were high levels of social vulnerability and who later committed numerous sexual crimes according to numerous investigations and reports. Haitian sociologist Sabine Lamour said in an interview that feminist and women’s organizations have observed many cases of sexual abuse in locations such as Bombardopolis, Port-Salut, Gonaïves and Port-au-Prince, despite the fact that both the national government and foreign embassies showed no interest in tracking down the cases.

One year after the end of the last mission in Haiti, the Latin American nations—with the exception of Cuba and Venezuela, who abstained from participating—have yet to make a complete and joint assessment of the 15 years of occupation of the country. Nor have they offered a satisfactory response or policies of reparation to the victims of this extensive and costly unilateral war.

Lautaro Rivara is a fellow with the Independent Media Institute. He is a sociologist, researcher and poet. As a trained journalist, he participated as an activist in different spaces of communications work, covering tasks of editing, writing, radio broadcasts, and photography. During his two years in the Jean-Jacques Dessalines Brigade in Haiti he was responsible for communications and carried out political education with Haitian people’s movements in this area. He writes regularly in people’s media projects of Argentina and the rest of Latin America and the Caribbean including Nodal, ALAI, Telesur, Resumen Latinoamericano, Pressenza, la RedH, Notas, Haití Liberte, Alcarajo, and more.

This article was produced by the Independent Media Institute.

COMMENTS?

Please join the conversation on Black Agenda Report's Facebook page at http://facebook.com/blackagendareport

Or, you can comment by emailing us at [email protected]

Haiti

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles. Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

The Black Alliance for Peace Welcomes Delayed Security Council Vote on Western Invasion of Haiti
Black Alliance For Peace
The Black Alliance for Peace Welcomes Delayed Security Council Vote on Western Invasion of Haiti
26 October 2022
The Black Alliance for Peace amplifies the demand of the Haitian people. UN representatives of the Peoples Republic of China and the Russian Fe
COMMENTARY: The Audacity of Hopelessness, John Maxwell, 2009
Editors, The Black Agenda Review
COMMENTARY: The Audacity of Hopelessness, John Maxwell, 2009
28 September 2022
The late Jamaican journalist John Maxwell on imperialism, underdevelopment, and the foreign love affair with Haiti’s misery.
At Least One Person Dead After a New Day of Anti-Government Protests in Haiti
Peoples Dispatch
At Least One Person Dead After a New Day of Anti-Government Protests in Haiti
07 September 2022
Haitians have been mobilizing against the Ariel Henry administration’s inability to combat crime, inflation and poverty.
 BAR Book Forum: Crystal Eddins’ Book, “Rituals, Runaways, and the Haitian Revolution”
Roberto Sirvent, BAR Book Forum Editor
BAR Book Forum: Crystal Eddins’ Book, “Rituals, Runaways, and the Haitian Revolution”
20 July 2022
In this series, we ask acclaimed authors to answer five questions about their book.
An Open Letter to His Excellency, Mr. Andrés Manuel López Obrador (AMLO), President of Mexico, on the Renewal of the UN Occupation of Haiti
Black Alliance for Peace
An Open Letter to His Excellency, Mr. Andrés Manuel López Obrador (AMLO), President of Mexico, on the Renewal of the UN Occupation of Haiti
13 July 2022
The United Nations occupation of Haiti under MINUSTAH and BINUH brought instability, violence, and even cholera to that nation.
Haiti: The Ransom is Still Being Paid
Robert Roth
Haiti: The Ransom is Still Being Paid
06 July 2022
The acknowledgement that France and the U.S. robbed Haiti of billions of dollars is long overdue.
Haiti| UN: twenty organizations say "No to the renewal of BINUH!
Rezo Nodwes
Haiti| UN: twenty organizations say "No to the renewal of BINUH!"
22 June 2022
The Security Council must say no to continuing interference in Haiti's affairs through the United Nations Integrated office in Haiti (BINUH).
Haiti and the Americas Syllabus
Haiti/Americas Committee Black Alliance For Peace
Haiti and the Americas Syllabus
08 June 2022
The Black Alliance for Peace Haiti-Americas Team Syllabus
Summit of the Americas or Summit of the United States of America?
Bertony Dupont
Summit of the Americas or Summit of the United States of America?
31 May 2022
The U.S. is using the upcoming Summit of the Americas to bully the rest of the region. The current puppet leader of Haiti must follow U.S.
Is the U.S. Covering Up its Role in Moïse’s Murder?
Kim Ives
Is the U.S. Covering Up its Role in Moïse’s Murder?
18 May 2022
The judge presiding over the trial of an accused killer of Haitian president Jovenel Moise granted the DOJ request to classify certain evidence

More Stories


  • Robert F. Kennedy Jr.:  Sheepdogging and Liberal Fantasy
    Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
    Robert F. Kennedy Jr.: Sheepdogging and Liberal Fantasy
    31 May 2023
    There is an understandable yearning for a progressive president. But like dreams of happily ever after endings, the fantasy is just that.
  • TRANSCRIPT: The Roots and Consequences of African Underdevelopment, Walter Rodney, 1979
    Editors, The Black Agenda Review
    TRANSCRIPT: The Roots and Consequences of African Underdevelopment, Walter Rodney, 1979
    31 May 2023
    In May 1979, the Center for Afro-American Studies at the University of California, Los Angeles hosted a symposium titled The Political Economy of the Black World. We are publishing, for the first…
  • Putin, South Africa, and the International Criminal Court
    Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
    Putin, South Africa, and the International Criminal Court
    31 May 2023
    The West has deployed the International Criminal Court in the US/NATO proxy war with Russia in Ukraine.
  • 2 Pentagon Parties= 1% Kabuki Theater/0 ‘debt ceiling’
    Raymond Nat Turner, BAR poet-in-residence
    2 Pentagon Parties= 1% Kabuki Theater/0 ‘debt ceiling’
    31 May 2023
                                                                                                                        2 Pentagon Parties=
  • BAR Book Forum: Naa Oyo A. Kwate’s Book, “White Burgers, Black Cash”
    Roberto Sirvent, BAR Book Forum Editor
    BAR Book Forum: Naa Oyo A. Kwate’s Book, “White Burgers, Black Cash”
    31 May 2023
    This week’s featured author is Naa Oyo A. Kwate. Kwate is associate professor of Africana studies and human ecology at Rutgers. Her book is White Burgers, Black Cash: Fast Food from Black Exclusion…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us