Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Freedom Rider: No Justice Without a Movement
Margaret Kimberley, BAR senior columnist
29 Apr 2021
🖨️ Print Article
Freedom Rider: No Justice Without a Movement
Freedom Rider: No Justice Without a Movement

The changes needed are fundamental to a country which puts anti-black racism at the center of politics, law and economics.

“There is little in the way of justice, and focusing solely on police snuff films is a poor substitute for meaningful analysis.”

The depth of public connection with George Floyd was clear on the day the verdict of his police killer was announced. The moment was awaited with trepidation and the guilty verdict was met with enthusiasm and in some cases outright joy. But at the same time that the world learned the perpetrator’s fate, a 16-year old named Ma’Khia Bryant was also killed by the police.

Police in the United States kill more than 1,000 people every year, an average of three every day. Had young Ms. Bryant been killed on any other date, it is probable that no one outside of her immediate circle would know her name either.

But demands for justice must be expanded beyond the latest police lynching that the media may choose to expose. Black people rank high on the list of every negative measure, such as homelessness or incarceration, and low on that which is positive, such as good health and living wage incomes. There is little in the way of justice, and focusing solely on police snuff films is a poor substitute for meaningful analysis.

“Had young Ms. Bryant been killed on any other date, it is probable that no one outside of her immediate circle would know her name.”

The focus on modern day lynch law at the expense of other issues not only hasn’t ended this scourge but it has given scoundrels an entree to practice their con games against Black people. After Floyd was murdered every hustler from Al Sharpton to Nancy Pelosi jumped on the bandwagon to voice fake outrage. Sharpton gives cover to the establishment and protects them like an old school gangster while pretending to fight for the people. As he famously told Joe Biden in a leaked video, “I will never embarrass you.”  

Pelosi and Democratic politicians made a mockery of a serious issue with their kente cloth, taking a knee stunt. One would think she couldn’t do any worse but she did. On the day of the verdict she opined that Floyd, “Sacrificed himself for justice.” Pelosi gets away with these insults because Black politics consists of the bottom feeding misleaders who owe their positions to her largesse. 

The issues are larger than most of us are willing to admit. The changes needed are fundamental to a country which puts anti-black racism at the center of politics, law and economics. The system demands that Black people be locked up, displaced, red lined, and prevented from having full citizenship rights. Police killings are just one manifestation of a fundamentally unjust nation.

“After Floyd was murdered every hustler from Al Sharpton to Nancy Pelosi jumped on the bandwagon to voice fake outrage.”

No one is complaining about the verdict aside from Floyd’s killer and other hard core racists. But that doesn’t mean that everyone’s interests are the same. The sigh of relief also belongs to people and institutions who are not our friends. It wasn’t just Pelosi and Congress who took a knee of phony concern, so did corporate CEOs and even police in some instances. The movement was a rare moment of consensus but everyone who took part didn’t do so for the same reason. While some genuinely sought redress, others wanted good public relations and cynical opportunities to raise a public profile. If the CEO of Chase bank takes a knee, the revolutionary moment has been lost. Aunt Jemima disappearing from the pancake box and the invention of terms like BIPOC are not victories. They are proof of failure.

If we must talk about former cop Derek Chauvin we must be honest. After the murder was filmed and made public the police in Minneapolis acted as they always do. Chauvin and the other police were fired and they hoped the people would be mollified. But they weren’t arrested until someone set fire to a police precinct. Suddenly nonchalance turned to urgency and the killer and his accomplices were arrested and charged.

“If the CEO of Chase bank takes a knee, the revolutionary moment has been lost.’

That moment was the beginning of a just legal outcome. It wasn’t just protest, but protest outside of the bounds that the politicians and CEOS found acceptable. Chauvin was shoved under the bus, lest the burgeoning movement be allowed to take hold and turn into something that couldn’t be controlled. 

It is fine to credit prosecutors with the way they handled their case, but thanks must also go to the person or persons who set the police station alight. They are probably more responsible than anyone else for the legal outcome. What little justice we get always comes when someone decides to push the envelope and threaten the system. If we are going to talk about justice it must be with some understanding and not wishful thinking. The verdict was the people’s verdict and that must not be forgotten.

Margaret Kimberley’s Freedom Rider column appears weekly in BAR, and is widely reprinted elsewhere. She maintains a frequently updated blog as well at http://freedomrider.blogspot.com . Ms. Kimberley lives in New York City, and can be reached via e-Mail at Margaret.Kimberley(at)BlackAgendaReport.com.

COMMENTS?

Please join the conversation on Black Agenda Report's Facebook page at http://facebook.com/blackagendareport

Or, you can comment by emailing us at comments@blackagendareport.com

George Floyd

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

Glen Ford, BAR Executive Editor
Time to Sharpen Our Weapons and Wits
27 May 2026
Six years ago, George Floyd was murdered by police.
Anthony Karefa Rogers-Wright
The Fall of 2020: How Liberals Ceded Solidarity and Engineered Social Justice Solitude
28 May 2025
The 2020 uprisings could have sparked a multiracial working-class movement against systemic oppression, but liberal elites defanged its radical
Black Alliance For Peace
From George Floyd Back to the Structural Violence of Capitalism
28 May 2025
With the ritualistic murder of George Floyd by the occupation forces referred to as the police that roam the streets and barrios of the Black a
Compliance Will Not Save Me
Ibram X. Kendi
Compliance Will Not Save Me
29 April 2021
American policing is defended as good despite its unmatched amounts of lethal violence.
Derek Chauvin and the Myth of the Impartial Juror
Sonali Chakravarti
Derek Chauvin and the Myth of the Impartial Juror
31 March 2021
As a space for democratic deliberation and decision-making, the jury box still has the potential to shift the criminal legal system – but first&…

More Stories


  • AfroLatinidad and Spirituality: An Interview with Guesnerth Josué Perea and Roberto Sirvent
    Roberto Sirvent, BAR Book Forum Editor , Guesnerth Josué Perea
    AfroLatinidad and Spirituality: An Interview with Guesnerth Josué Perea and Roberto Sirvent
    17 May 2023
    BAR Book Forum editor Roberto Sirvent discusses AfroLatinidad and spirituality with Guesnerth Josué Perea.
  • State of Impunity: Fire at Gold Mine Leaves 27 Dead in Arequipa
    Clau O'Brien Moscoso
    State of Impunity: Fire at Gold Mine Leaves 27 Dead in Arequipa
    17 May 2023
    A gold mine fire killed 27 men in Peru. The people in that nation are not just struggling against the coup regime, but against official corruption and the exploitation of people and their land.
  • Daniel Penny is The State
    Ashoka Jegroo
    Daniel Penny is The State
    17 May 2023
    Daniel Penny choked Jordan Neely to death on a New York City subway. He was deputized by the state to do so, and the state continues to defend him and assassinate Neely's character after his murder.
  • Atlanta to Host National Conference for Black Self-Determination and Pan-African Unity
    Tunde Osazua
    Atlanta to Host National Conference for Black Self-Determination and Pan-African Unity
    17 May 2023
    Community Movement Builders is hosting a National Black Radical Organizing Conference in Atlanta, Georgia from June 23 to June 25, "Connecting the national Black struggle for self-determination with…
  • U.S. Backs Dominican Republic As Violence Against Haitians Escalates After 22% of Haitians Deported
    Vladimir Fuentes
    U.S. Backs Dominican Republic As Violence Against Haitians Escalates After 22% of Haitians Deported
    17 May 2023
    The Dominican Republican continues acts of violence and deportations against Haitian descended people with near complete impunity as a result of making thousands of people stateless.
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us