Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire
  • omnibus

Foreign Aid for Rwanda, Suffering for Rwandans and Congolese
Ann Garrison, BAR contributor
04 Sep 2019
Foreign Aid for Rwanda, Suffering for Rwandans and Congolese
Foreign Aid for Rwanda, Suffering for Rwandans and Congolese

Rwanda is treated as a showcase of US-allied Africa, but even western capitalists don’t believe dictator Paul Kagame’s economic numbers, and his own fortune comes from looting Congo.

“Kagame is the Clintons’ darling — which is a no-no with Trump.”

Rwanda received roughly “$1.22 billion” in development aid in 2016-2017, the most recent year for which Official Development Aid (ODA) numbers are available on the website of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). The US was Rwanda’s top bilateral donor that year, giving $177.6 million, but Trump drastically reduced aid to the tiny East African nation. In December 2017, Rwandan-Canadian economist David Himbara, a former member of Kagame’s cabinet, wrote:

“Kagame-Trump relationship does not look good. When the American head of state invited African leaders at the United Nations in September 2017, Kagame was not among the invitees. The Rwandan dictator was deliberately left out in the cold. The issue seems to revolve around the fact that Kagame is the Clintons’ darling — which is a no-no with Trump.”

Himbara added that Rwanda would not be the only African nation facing reduced US aid because Trump had slashed the State Department’s overall budget.

Rwanda’s growth and poverty stats are Kagame’s own

Before Trump took office, the US, and most particularly its freelance envoy Bill Clinton, often boasted of US aid’s good effects in Rwanda by pointing to President Paul Kagame’s statistical fabrications about economic growth and decreasing poverty. On August 12, however, the Financial Times (FT) published a report titled “Rwanda: where even poverty data must toe Kagame's line.” (The article is paywalled, but Global Posthas reposted it.)

FT researchers analyzed data and concluded that poverty in Rwanda had actually increased by at least 6% during a period when the government said it had decreased. Last week BBC Radio’s Business Daily followed up with a report titled “Can we trust Rwanda's data?”, which affirmed the FT’s conclusions and also reported that aid given to help Rwandans switch from local food production to market production had actually impoverished farming communities and enriched middlemen. 

In July 2016, a headline in The East African read “Famine hits over 100,000 Rwandan families in Eastern province.” The report said that rural Rwandans were fleeing famine across the Rwandan border into Uganda. 

The BBC spoke to Rwandan-Canadian economist David Himbara, who said that when he was a minister in the Rwandan government, President Paul Kagame would give his cabinet officials orders as to the statistics he wanted them to report:

David Himbara: Basically, there are no credible statistics in Rwanda because the president decides what he wants and then the rest of government gives him what he wants to see. [Kagame says,] “I want to have grown by 11% last year.” [His ministers say,] “Yes, sir, that’s how much you grew.”

BBC: The president would simply say this is the number that will describe, let's say, economic growth, and then an official would say, “It will be so.”

DH: Yeah. Let me give you an example. In 2009 I was in this meeting where you had economic ministers, like Ministers of Finance, Agriculture, Trade and Industry. In this meeting, the president said he wanted [the economy] to have grown by 11%. The Minister of Finance at the time, he said, “Sir, in fact, you grew by 11.5%.”

Then when it came to my turn, I said, “It's not possible. It's not credible because in 2008 the whole world was upside down. There was a financial meltdown.” And he said, “Who are you [to deny me]? Just shut up.”

BBC: So your objections were overruled.

DH: Oh, absolutely.

Himbara is the author of “Kagame’s Economic Mirage” and the upcoming book “Kagame, Clinton, Blair, Jim Yong Kim, World Bank and Foreign Aid Fraud in Rwanda.”

Donors are complicit in Rwanda’s occupation of DRC

Whether donors contribute to general budget support or earmark funds for poverty relief and other alleged good works, they inevitably fund Rwanda’s ongoing, catastrophic occupation of DRC, where over four and a half million of 81 million Congolese are among the country’s ever-growing population of “internally displaced persons,” aka internal refugees. Four and a half million was the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR)’s best estimate at the conclusion of 2017.

In 2016-17, Rwanda received less than 2% of foreign aid as direct budget support, although 8.41% were vaguely earmarked as “multi-sector.” Direct budget support and conceivably multi-sector support were funds that Kagame was able to use as he saw fit, including Rwanda’s ongoing occupation and plunder of DRC.

“Donors inevitably fund Rwanda’s ongoing, catastrophic occupation of Democratic Republic of Congo.”

Other funds were earmarked for education, health, agriculture, and other domestic sectors. However, even if earmarked funds are indeed spent as earmarked, they indirectly fund the occupation and plunder by taking care of domestic goals and projects, however Kagame defines and implements them. Funds Kagame does not have to spend in Rwanda are free for aggression in Congo. This is the same obvious, ipso facto, sky blue, grass green conclusion that has appeared in annual reportsby the UN Group of Experts on the Democratic Republic of the Congo. 

In addition to aid donated for allegedly good works in Rwanda, which are not represented in OECD statistics, the US is a longtime contributor to Rwanda’s military budget, and has long described Rwanda as a “military partner” in the US Africa Command (AFRICOM). Trump, in keeping with his determination to turn the US military into a global protection racket, said that he would turn military grants into loans so that they would cost US taxpayers less.

Beni Massacres: Fake Islamists and Rwandan Unending Occupation

Anyone who doubts that Rwanda continues to occupy and plunder DRC should read Congolese author Boniface Musavuli’s latest book, Beni Massacres: Fake Islamists and Rwandan Unending Occupation, which has been published in an excellent French-to-English translation.

In the book’s foreword, Congolese Professor of African Studies Georges Nzongola-Ntalaja, University of North Carolina, writes:

“This is the context in which we must place the Beni massacres. They are a logical sequel to all other crimes committed by the RPA/RDF [Rwandan Patriotic Army/Rwandan Defense Force] since 1990 in the pursuit of Tutsi hegemony and the two Kivu Provinces in the DRC.

“A major affirmation of Musavuli's book is that the DRC is a country under occupation and tutelage by Rwanda. When the AFDL [Alliance of Democratic Forces for the Liberation of Congo] entered the country from Rwanda and Uganda in October 1996, it was led by James Kabarebe, a Rwandan military officer close to Kagame. Laurent-Désiré Kabila (LDK), the AFDL leader, had no control over military operations, as they were supervised by Kabarebe. When LDK broke with his mentors in July 1998, he made the mistake of retaining Joseph Kabila, who is apparently related to Kabarebe and once served as a Rwandan intelligence officer. The creation of the Rassemblement Congolais pour la Démocratie [Rally for Congolese Democracy] in August 1998 allowed Kigali to send back most of the soldiers who had come to the Congo with the AFDL, many of whom are still officers of the Armed Forces of the DRC (FARDC) today.”

(The “Alliance of Democratic Forces for the Liberation of Congo” and the “Rally for Congolese Democracy” were Rwandan and Ugandan forces which disguised Rwanda and Uganda’s invasion and occupation of Congo by assuming Congolese names. Later fraudulent names for Rwandan and Ugandan forces included the “National Congress for the Defence of the People (CNDP)” and the infamous March 23rd Movement (M23).)

2012-2013: DRC won the war, M23 the rewards

The atrocities that M23 committed in DRC caused such international outrage that it finally spurred the US and the UN Security Council to action, but their solution was ultimately as fraudulent as the Congolese names of Rwandan and Ugandan forces in DRC. The UNSC deployed a UN combat brigade to chase M23 back into Rwanda and Uganda, where they “surrendered” to the Rwandan and Ugandan governments. This was like saying that during the US Civil War, the Union Army chased Confederate troops back into the Deep South to surrender to Robert E. Lee.

Then US billionaire investor Howard Buffett (son of Warren), who has resource interests in the region, paid for a “peace conference” in Uganda, which concluded with DRC and M23 signing a contractual “Declaration” including this Article 10:

“The government [meaning the DRC] reaffirms its determination to finalize the implementation of the commitments that have been made under the agreement of March 23, 2009, signed with the CNDP.”

In other words, Congo won the war, but Rwanda and Uganda—via their M23 militia—were rewarded with everything they’d demanded when they started it. The March 23, 2009, agreement had been a de facto surrender of territory to Rwanda and Uganda’s CNDP militia, but Rwanda and Uganda created M23 four years later because they weren’t satisfied with what they were getting out of that deal.

On Jan. 2, 2014, less than a month after DRC signed away the store to Rwanda and Uganda, the country’s beloved Colonel Mamadou N’Dala Moustafa, who had led the military defeat of M23, was assassinated in Congo’s Beni Territory, in a fiery attack on a vehicle he was traveling in.

I asked David Himbara how Kagame fits all the money gained by plundering Congo’s immense resources into his budget. He replied, “DR Congo money does not go into the Rwandan economy. The loot goes into offshore accounts of Crystal Ventures Ltd and its owner Kagame.”

Ann Garrison is an independent journalist based in the San Francisco Bay Area. In 2014, she received the Victoire Ingabire Umuhoza Democracy and Peace Prize for her reporting on conflict in the African Great Lakes region. She can be reached at ann(at)anngarrison.com 

COMMENTS?

Please join the conversation on Black Agenda Report's Facebook page at http://facebook.com/blackagendareport

Or, you can comment by emailing us at [email protected]

Kagame Rwandan dictatorship

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles. Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.

Trending

Elizabeth Warren Wants Green Bombs, not a Green New Deal
Parallels Between Black and Palestinian Struggles
Cory Booker Hates Public Schools
Bill Cosby Should Have Been Denounced by Black America Long Ago
The Black Wall Around Barack Obama: Who Does It Protect Him Against?
How Complacency, Complicity of Black Misleadership Class Led to Supreme Court Evisceration of the Voting Rights Act

Related Stories

Rusesabagina’s Show Trial and Shooting Deaths of a Rwandan Dissident and an Italian Ambassador
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
Rusesabagina’s Show Trial and Shooting Deaths of a Rwandan Dissident and an Italian Ambassador
24 February 2021
Is there any limit to how far the West will go to cover for Rwandan President Paul Kagame’s Crimes? asks Ann Garrison.
Kizito Mihigo and the Struggle for Rwandan Truth and Reconciliation
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
Kizito Mihigo and the Struggle for Rwandan Truth and Reconciliation
17 February 2021
Rwandans around the world celebrate the life of the nation’s most popular singer, apparently killed for opposing Paul Kagame’s ethnic and military
Top-Secret Testimonies Implicate Rwanda’s President in War Crimes
Judi Rever and Benedict Moran
Top-Secret Testimonies Implicate Rwanda’s President in War Crimes
02 December 2020
Previously suppressed evidence shows that dictator Paul Kagame’s forces slaughtered hundreds of thousands of Hutus – the other side of the Rwandan
America’s Wars on Democracy in Rwanda and the DRC
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
America’s Wars on Democracy in Rwanda and the DRC
21 October 2020
This is an excellent chronicling of the Rwandan government’s racist policies toward the majority Hutu population, writes Ann Garrison.
Freeing “Hotel Rwanda” Hero Paul Rusesabagina
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
Freeing “Hotel Rwanda” Hero Paul Rusesabagina
14 October 2020
The man portrayed by Don Cheadle in the movie about mass slaughter in Rwanda was kidnapped and jailed by the country’s dictator, writes Ann Garriso
Who is Rwanda’s Real Hero? Paul Kagame or Paul Rusesabagina?
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
Who is Rwanda’s Real Hero? Paul Kagame or Paul Rusesabagina?
30 September 2020
What Kagame has done to Rusesabagina, of Hotel Rwanda fame, embarrasses the US foreign policy establishment that has lionized his brutal regime for
It’s Time to Acknowledge Hutu Genocide and Rwandan Occupation of DR Congo
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
It’s Time to Acknowledge Hutu Genocide and Rwandan Occupation of DR Congo
09 September 2020
“Global power elites are silent about Hutu genocide and Rwanda’s ongoing occupation of the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC),” writes Ann Garrison
Rwanda: “Victoire Ingabire Should Be Arrested at Least, Killed at Best”
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
Rwanda: “Victoire Ingabire Should Be Arrested at Least, Killed at Best”
27 May 2020
The life of the woman who leads Rwanda’s most prominent opposition to Paul Kagame’s dictatorship is being publicly threatened in the wake of the ki
The Shocking Death of Rwandan Gospel Singer and Dissident Kizito Mihigo
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
The Shocking Death of Rwandan Gospel Singer and Dissident Kizito Mihigo
19 February 2020
I would like to say that President Kagame has finally gone too far, that the powerful industrial nations will finally stop running cover for his cr
Victoire Ingabire Walks a Knife Edge in Rwanda
Ann Garrison , BAR contributor
Victoire Ingabire Walks a Knife Edge in Rwanda
20 November 2019
The mass murderer that the US helped put in power in Rwanda flew into a raging rant against the woman who symbolizes the hopes of that country’s ma

More Stories


  • Freedom Rider: No Human Rights in Texas
    Margaret Kimberley, BAR senior columnist
    Freedom Rider: No Human Rights in Texas
    24 Feb 2021
    The people of Texas suffer unnecessarily from bad weather because their state puts oligarchs first and does not recognize the human right to health and safety.
  • BLACK CITIZENSHIP FORUM: The Roots of Xenophobic Violence in South Africa—A Pan African Response
    Black Agenda Review Editors
    BLACK CITIZENSHIP FORUM: The Roots of Xenophobic Violence in South Africa—A Pan African Response
    24 Feb 2021
    South Africa must dismantle and transcend the colonial nation-state through creation of a Pan-African federation that stretches across the Southern African sub-continent.
  • Rusesabagina’s Show Trial and Shooting Deaths of a Rwandan Dissident and an Italian Ambassador
    Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
    Rusesabagina’s Show Trial and Shooting Deaths of a Rwandan Dissident and an Italian Ambassador
    24 Feb 2021
    Is there any limit to how far the West will go to cover for Rwandan President Paul Kagame’s Crimes? asks Ann Garrison.
  • Democracy Now Provides Progressive Cover to State Department Propaganda Campaign Against China 
    Danny Haiphong, BAR Contributing Editor
    Democracy Now Provides Progressive Cover to State Department Propaganda Campaign Against China 
    24 Feb 2021
    The show has become a reliable platform for uncritical regime change propaganda, demonizing targets of US empire from Syria to Nicaragua.
  • He’s under suspicion…
    Raymond Nat Turner, BAR poet-in-residence
    He’s under suspicion…
    24 Feb 2021
    The rioters all knew him— it had to be an inside job— ‘cause to a man they spoke to him by name as they breached the building. Read their lips…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us