Is Barack Obama Good For Black People? The Great Debate in Harlem, Part 2 of 2 | Black Agenda Report

Is Barack Obama Good For Black People? The Great Debate in Harlem, Part 2 of 2

Bill Quigley

12 Aug 2009

🖨️ Print Article

On June 25, hundreds of black America's formost thnkers and doers gathered at St. Mary's Church in Harlem NY to ask and answer the question of whether Barack Obama was good or bad for black America. We here present some of the 5 to 7 minute presentations pro and con on whether Barack Obama is good for black America. Click the flash players to listen to or the mics to download them in MP3 format.

Glen Ford

The fact, says Dr. Jared Ball of Morgan State University and voxunion.com, is that Barack Obama did not emerge from the struggle of our people for peace and justice. He has been imposed upon us by outside forces in answer to that struggle, not in fulfillment of it..

Charles Barron

While NY City Councilman Charles Barron disagrees with some of Obama's policies, he seems to draw a line around those who disagree with the president, calling them “intellectuals” who he says, do the hood no good.

Dr. Marimba Ani

Give the brotha a break? Dr. Marimba Ani doesn't think we should give the American empire a break. If anything, she notes, having a black man sitting in the big chair makes it harder to fight.

Charles Barron

argues that Barack Obama represents incremental but significant change, and even though the election was eight months ago, reaches back to compare Obama with McCain.

Viola Plummer

Barack Obama is a “yes we can” symbol of national unity for black people, says Viola Plummer.

.

Diop Olugbala

The Uhuru Movement's Diop Olugbala argues that a lesser evil is still quite evil. We can, he insists, do better.

Click here for part one of the Great Debate in Harlem, with Glen Ford, Dr. Leonard Jeffries, Nellie Bailey and Dr. Gloria Browne Marshall

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.

More Stories

Raymond Nat Turner, BAR poet-in-residence
Spinning Half-truth straw into big lie gold…
14 Jan 2026
"Spinning Half-truth straw into big lie gold…" is the latest from BAR's Poet-in-Residence.
Anthony Karefa Rogers-Wright
The Domestic Global South and The Need for Climate and Environmental Internationalism
14 Jan 2026
True environmental liberation demands south-to-south solidarity against racial capitalism, linking the struggles of oppressed communities from Palestine to Louisiana under a shared framework of…
Pan-African Community Action
Occupation Forces Upheld by Federal Judiciary Demonstrates DC’s Need for Community Control
14 Jan 2026
While politicians debate legal procedure, residents of Washington DC live under a sustained military deployment, exposing how both federal and local power collaborate against them.
Hanna Eid
Hyperscale Data Centers and the Production of Waste
14 Jan 2026
The A.I. revolution has a hidden cost. Its massive data centers create huge amounts of waste and decimate labor and humanity.
Willie Mack
Trump 2.0: A dark mirror into our past
14 Jan 2026
The Trump 2.0 administration is demonstrating the logical endpoint of a state project built on racial oppression. Trump’s actions show continuity with past history.