Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire
  • omnibus

There’s Nothing "Transformative" About Bernie Sanders (He’s Just Not Hillary)
Glen Ford, BAR executive editor
18 Feb 2016
bernie
At most he's not Hillary. and at least he's not Hillary. but his plan B IS Hillary

Bernie Sanders’ domestic policies more clearly match Black America’s left-leaning politics – but they will still reject him in favor of Hillary Clinton, who Blacks think has a better chance against the Republicans. At any rate, Sanders is no prize. He is "incapable of challenging his own party and president on domestic economic policy, and has no substantive objections to Obama or Clinton on foreign policy."

“Sanders cannot divorce himself from – or even cease praising – the president and the party that has been a full partner in creating the economic devastation he so dutifully cites at every campaign stop.”

Black America, the most left-leaning constituency in the United States on issues of social and economic justice and peace, will ensure that corporate mercenary and pathological warlord Hilllary Clinton wins the Democratic presidential nomination. The ax will fall in the South Carolina Democratic primary on the last Saturday of this month, when Blacks overwhelmingly reject the appeals of self-identified “democratic socialist” Bernie Sanders, a candidate whose positions on domestic issues are much closer to their own. A CNN poll shows Clinton leading Sanders 65 to 28 percent, although the Vermont Senator will doubtless close the gap a bit over the next ten days. White Democrats, a minority of the state Party, break 54% for Sanders, bringing his current share of the primary vote to 38 percent.

The statistic that is key to understanding the great paradox is that 75 percent of Black voters view Clinton as having a better chance to defeat the Republicans in November. In the context of the U.S. duopoly system, that’s all Black folks need to know, or think they know, to make a decision in national elections. For Blacks, the Democratic Party’s purpose is to beat back the existential threat posed by the Republicans, the White Man’s Party, whose organizing principle is white supremacy. (See “Throw Off the Dead Weight of the Democratic Party,” BAR, February 10, 2016.) All else is considered secondary, or irrelevant.

“The party’s rich masters know full well that Blacks seek protection, not accountability, from the Democrats.”

This overarching imperative to support the party that is thought to keep the ever-resurgent Confederate barbarians outside the White House gates enfeebles Black voters, even when they are most strategically placed to affect significant electoral change. Although Blacks make up about a quarter of the Democratic Party, their actual influence within the party structure is minimal – profoundly self-limiting – because they perceive themselves as having nowhere else to go. The party’s rich masters know full well that Blacks seek protection, not accountability, from the Democrats, and will therefore subordinate their own progressive politics to the electoral needs of the party. They support a winner, rather than a torch-bearer or co-struggler. White Democrats are demonstrably not so constrained, which is why we see the maddening paradox in the current landscape in which young whites support Sanders, the less onerous Democrat, while Blacks stick like glue to the most heavily capitalized, right-wing of the national party (which is also why whites make up the bulk of leftist, independent party voters).

Under such circumstances, the best thing that Bernie Sanders could have done is made the case that he has a better chance of defeating the Republicans than Clinton. Some polls indicate that Sanders is, indeed, a better match against the GOP field, but Politifact.com has concluded that the evidence is ambiguous, and the Sanders camp has failed to play this card forcefully enough. Ambiguity might have been all it took to sway sufficient Black voters to the candidate whose politics more closely resembles their own, but Sander’s fate will almost surely be sealed by a Black landslide for Clinton – the purported GOP-slayer – two Saturdays from now, in South Carolina.

“The best thing that Bernie Sanders could have done is made the case that he has a better chance of defeating the Republicans than Clinton.”

Given the warped relationship of Blacks to the Democratic Party – a “trap within the trap” of the Rich Man’s Duopoly system – it is no wonder that the Black side of the party has become a stagnant sewage pool of corruption, a breeding ground of hustlers whose primal instinct is to attach themselves to a “winner” with deep pockets. At least 12 Black congresspersons have descended on South Carolina on Hillary Clinton’s behalf. Last week, the Congressional Black Caucus PAC endorsed Clinton. The PAC’s board, infested with corporate lobbyists, includes seven House members, including all three of the Blacks that voted for President Obama’s Trans Pacific Partnership: Eddie Bernice Johnson (TX), Gregory Meeks (NY), and Terri Sewell (AL). Sewell registered the lowest score of any member in BAR’s CBC Monitor Report Card for last year.

Clinton has shamelessly wrapped herself in the shroud of Obama’s lame duck presidency, hoping to become the third “Black” in the White House (the second in her household). In the last debate, Clinton confirmed that President Obama is just as beholden to Wall Street as she is. Candidate Obama “was the recipient of the largest number of donations ever,” said Clinton, correctly. But, “when it mattered, he stood up and took on Wall Street,” she added, lying through her teeth. Naturally, Sanders, locked tightly in his chosen party straitjacket, had no proper response, which is just one of an infinity of examples of why there can be no transformation of the Democratic Party “from below,” and why the party is incapable of challenging Wall Street. He cannot divorce himself from – or even cease praising – the president and the party that has been a full partner in creating the economic devastation he so dutifully cites at every campaign stop. This must be what one hand clapping sounds like.

“Clinton’s and Obama’s foreign policy is Sanders’ default policy.”

About 5,000 pairs of hands were clapping for Sanders at a campaign rally at predominantly Black Morehouse College, in Atlanta, Tuesday night. Chants of “Bernie! Bernie! Bernie” rang from the gymnasium rafters, as two Black politicians and Atlanta-based rapper Killer Mike sang the candidate’s praises. Sanders called for demilitarizing the police, abolishing the death penalty, and rebuilding Flint, Michigan.

In Ypsilanti, Michigan, Sanders showed 10,000 admirers that he wasn’t a “one-issue” candidate by outlining his positions on at least 20 separate issues. However, only one of them concerned foreign policy. Sanders reminded everyone that he voted against giving George Bush War Powers to invade Iraq. If the U.S. can spend all those billions on Iraq, he said, then it can invest in priorities back home. Right?

Wrong. Clinton’s and Obama’s foreign policy is Sanders’ default policy. He wants to fund his domestic revitalization and the empire, too – a political and economic impossibility and a moral abyss. Thus, we see that Sanders is incapable of challenging his own party and president on domestic economic policy, as previously discussed, and has no substantive objections to Obama or Clinton on foreign policy.

There is nothing transformative happening here, especially regarding Black politics, which is strangled and mutilated under the same duopoly system that straitjackets Sanders (if he really needs a jacket).

The action is in the streets.

BAR executive editor Glen Ford can be contacted at [email protected].
Democrats
Berniecrats
2016 presidential election

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles. Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

2016 Revisited: Electronic Balloting Favored Clinton, Paper Balloting Sanders
Ann Garrison , BAR contributor
2016 Revisited: Electronic Balloting Favored Clinton, Paper Balloting Sanders
25 September 2019
Investigators call it “strange patterns in data”— that saw Hillary Clinton win primaries with electronic ballots, and Bernie Sanders victorious in
Joe Biden Wants Us to Forget His Past. We Won't
Adolph Reed , Cornel West
Joe Biden Wants Us to Forget His Past. We Won't
08 May 2019
Joe Biden is the purest example of the corporate Democrats that turned the party decisively towards war, austerity and race-baiting in a previous e
Bernie and Barbara: What’s Wrong With This Picture?
Ann Garrison , BAR contributor
Bernie and Barbara: What’s Wrong With This Picture?
31 October 2018
How can Bernie Sanders or Barbara Lee keep any of their social democratic promises while scapegoating Russia?
The Color of Economic Anxiety
Malaika Jabali
The Color of Economic Anxiety
10 October 2018
  Is the collapse of Democratic fortunes due to economic anxiety? Just ask Black Milwaukeeans.
Democratic Party Politics 101 with Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the Corporate Media
Danny Haiphong , BAR contributor
Democratic Party Politics 101 with Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the Corporate Media
25 July 2018
“Democrats have firmly implanted themselves on the side of Wall Street and its militarist corporate partners.”
Bernie Sanders: “Don’t Be Rude to White Nationalists, Do What Alexandria Did”
Paul Street
Bernie Sanders: “Don’t Be Rude to White Nationalists, Do What Alexandria Did”
11 July 2018
“People Have a Right to Go Into a Restaurant and Have Dinner”
Freedom Rider: Ocasio-Cortez and the Left
Margaret Kimberley , BAR editor and senior columnist
Freedom Rider: Ocasio-Cortez and the Left
04 July 2018
“Ocasio-Cortez deserves credit for beating a corrupt but powerful system.”
Why the Green Party Hasn't Taken Off
Bruce A. Dixon , BAR managing editor
Why Our Green Parties Haven't Taken Off
30 May 2018
A solid majority of Americans polled want to see a third party compete with Republicans and Democrats.
Barber Sermon on Militarism Reveals Philosophical & Political Limitations of the Poor Peoples Campaign
Bruce A. Dixon , BAR managing editor
Barber Sermon on Militarism Reveals Philosophical & Political Limitations of the Poor Peoples Campaign
11 May 2018
"Rev.
Danny Haiphong , BAR contributor
The Democratic “Deep State” Takeover and the Moribund State of American Politics
11 April 2018
“Democrats make gun violence in America the primary midterm election issue because the passage of single payer healthcare, a scale back

More Stories


  • Black Agenda Radio March 31, 2023
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Black Agenda Radio March 31, 2023
    31 Mar 2023
    20th anniversary of Iraq invasion and the Ukraine proxy war, immigration policies remain unchanged, and New York prosecutors discriminate against prospective jurors of color.
  • Ray McGovern Connects Anniversary of Iraq Invasion and Ukraine Proxy War - Part 2
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Ray McGovern Connects Anniversary of Iraq Invasion and Ukraine Proxy War - Part 2
    31 Mar 2023
    Ray McGovern served as a CIA analyst for 27 years, from the administration of John F. Kennedy to that of George H. W. Bush.
  • Biden's Punitive Immigration Policies - Part 2
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Biden's Punitive Immigration Policies - Part 2
    31 Mar 2023
    Aly Wane is on the advisory board of the Immigrant Justice Network.
  • New York Prosecutors Discriminate Against Jurors and Defendants of Color
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    New York Prosecutors Discriminate Against Jurors and Defendants of Color
    31 Mar 2023
    Ten ethics complaints were filed against prosecutors across New York state, alleging discrimination against prospective jurors of color.
  • INTERVIEW: Randall Robinson: Third World Advocate, 1983
    Editors, The Black Agenda Review
    INTERVIEW: Randall Robinson: Third World Advocate, 1983
    29 Mar 2023
    Remembering Randall Robinson: Black internationalist, anti-imperialist, and friend of Haiti.
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us