Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.  If you broadcast our audio commentaries please consider a recurring donation to Black Agenda Report.

South Africa and Zimbabwe: A Tale of Two Land Reforms

  • Sharebar
    Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version

    by Harold Green


    When Zimbabwe’s Robert Mugabe attended the memorial service for Nelson Mandela, he “received the loudest cheers and applause” among the dignitaries. Zimbabwe’s successful land reform stands in stark contrast to South Africa, where “barely 10% of farm land has been redistributed,” and the wealth gap – which is a race gap – “has become one of the most unequal in the world.”


    South Africa and Zimbabwe: A Tale of Two Land Reforms

    by Harold Green

    “Zimbabwe's land reform has resulted in hundreds of thousands of Black Zimbabweans becoming new and successful farmers.”

    While Nelson Mandela and the ANC are to be praised for their courageous and persistent commitment to ending the racist and brutal system of Apartheid including having taken up arms against it, the question many have begun to ask: How true did they stay to that commitment upon being released from prison and eventually coming to power. The answer to that question can be found in understanding what the specific goals and objectives were of the various South African organizations involved in the Anti-Apartheid Movement.

    For Nelson Mandela and the ANC (the most prominent South African anti-apartheid group) they're goals and objectives were crystallized in the ANC's 1955 Freedom Charter. Controversial when it was created, many like Robert Sobukwe who thought it was not nationalistic, not “African” enough, left the ANC to go on to form other anti-apartheid groups. In the case of Robert Sobukwe, he and other former members of the ANC, would go on to form the Pan African Congress in 1959.

    Despite the controversial multiracial aspect of the Freedom Charter, there was one important demand in it to which everyone did agree: that land ownership would be the right to all. In the section entitled, “The Land Shall be Shared Among Those Who Work It!” it states:

    “Restrictions of land ownership on a racial basis shall be ended, and all the land re-divided amongst those who work it to banish famine and land hunger;

    The state shall help the peasants with implements, seed, tractors and dams to save the soil and assist the tillers;

    Freedom of movement shall be guaranteed to all who work on the land;

    All shall have the right to occupy land wherever they choose;”

    Land reform and redistribution was clearly one of the main focal points of the anti-Apartheid movement. While the issue of pass laws, housing, fair compensation for labor, human rights, etc, were important, it was the issue of land, especially among Black South Africans, that factored significantly in the fight to end Apartheid.

    ”White land owners began asking for far more than what the land was worth leading to inflated land values.”

    When Nelson Mandela and the ANC came to power, they made sure the issue of land reform was included in the new constitution. In it, the right to have access to land was guaranteed, albeit with the problematic caveat that there would be no “arbitrary expropriation,” and that land could only be acquired on a “willing seller, willing buyer” basis.

    Despite some early successes, the willing seller, willing buyer stipulation has proven to be problematic. White land owners began asking for far more than what the land was worth leading to inflated land values, and making it virtually impossible for the government to sustain funding. Encouragingly, the willing seller, willing buyer stipulation is being abandoned, and a new expropriation bill has been introduced (March 2013) in response to demands that land reform take place on a more equitable basis.

    Upon coming to power in 1994 (two years before the new constitution was implemented), the ANC through it's Restitution of Land Rights Act enacted in 1994 and it's Reconstruction and Development Programme (RDP) promised agricultural and land reform. It's stated goal was to put 30% of the 90% of farm land held by whites into the hands of Black farmers, and to settle the hundreds of thousands restitution claims by those Blacks who could prove their families land had been stolen under Apartheid.

    Those goals were to have been achieved by 2000. To date, barely 10% of farm land has been redistributed. Sadly, 90% of the resulting farms have failed due to insufficient funding that was promised under the Restitution of Land Rights Act. Bewilderingly, the vast majority of Black South Africans whose land was stolen and thusly had legitimate claims for restitution, have missed the poorly advertised deadline for filing restitution claims with no second chances. Many others have been forced to accept meager payments for land that was stolen, far below current market value. In a word, land reform in South Africa under ANC leadership 20 years hence, has been a “disaster.”

    Understandably, Black South Africans are loosing patience with the ineffective manner in which land reform has been carried out. Many are beginning to look at the land reform process implemented by ZANU-PF under the leadership of Robert Mugabe in Zimbabwe, and are questioning whether this approach should be followed by the ANC. The leadership of the ANC, in no rush to upset the economic apple cart that has made many of them rich, are scampering to ward off the growing discontent over the slow pace of land reform and other economic justice issues.

    Despite the continuous racist ad hominem attacks against Robert Mugabe, coupled with economic sanctions in an attempt to destroy Zimbabwe's land reform agenda, land reform in Zimbabwe is moving along with a considerable degree of success. As evidenced in a host of books and reports published in recent years, most notably Zimbabwe's Fast Track Land Reform by Prosper D. Matondi and Zimbabwe Takes Its Land Back by Joseph Hanlon, Zimbabwe's land reform in spite of it's tumultuous and long overdue start, has resulted in hundreds of thousands of Black Zimbabweans becoming new and successful farmers.

    "To date, barely 10% of farm land has been redistributed.”

    These reports dispel the racist myths about famine and food shortages due to failing Black farms. What these reports reveal is that these new Black farms are just as profitable as the white owned farms were, producing sufficient food for both Zimbabwe's export and domestic markets.

    What is also proving to be successful is Zimbabwe's indigenization program administered through Zimbabwe's Youth, Indigenization and Economic Empowerment ministry. This requires that all foreign companies operating in Zimbabwe sell at least 51% of ownership of the respective companies to local Zimbabweans. Having learned their lesson from the land reform episode that saw ZANU-PF prevail, these foreign companies are offering little resistance to indigenization.

    No such indigenization program exist for Black South Africans. Instead, there is the Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) program administered under South Africa's Department of Trade and Industry. It's stated purpose is to: “focus on broadening participation, equity and access to redress for all economic citizens, particularly those previously marginalized”

    The BEE list a host of objectives designed to more fully integrate Black South Africans into the South African economy by encouraging Black ownership and entrepreneurship. However, instead of the masses benefiting, there has been a rush by the leadership of the ANC, and other well connected Blacks, to become minority partners and sit on boards of various white owned companies.

    This grotesque scenario has prompted Moeletsi Mbeki, brother of former South African president Thabo Mbeki to comment, “it [BEE] strikes the fatal blow against the emergence of black entrepreneurship by creating a small class of unproductive but wealthy black crony capitalists made up of ANC politicians, some retired and others not, who have become strong allies of the economic oligarchy.” It is no secret that corruption amongst ANC's leadership has become pandemic, while the wealth gap between rich and poor (mostly Black) has become one of the most unequal in the world.

    As frustration and anger grows among Black South Africans, particularly among Black South African youth who make up 77% of South Africa's population, and who are 70% of the unemployed, coupled with continuing intransigence on the part of white South Africans in their unwillingness to relinquish accumulated advantages, the ANC may very well be facing a Zimbabwean type scenario which they might not be able to control.

    ”Corruption amongst ANC's leadership has become pandemic.”

    Black South African youth view Robert Mugabe as a hero for not only taking back African land from white farmers, but also for successfully standing up to the most powerful economic forces in the world as they imposed near crippling sanctions in their attempt to destroy Zimbabwe's economy and force Robert Mugabe and ZANU-PF from power. No surprise then that at the recent memorial service for Nelson Mandela in Johannesburg, he received the loudest cheers and applause, as well as a standing ovation when acknowledge as one of the attending dignitaries.

    If Zimbabwean type scenarios are to break out in South Africa, while surely to be condemned by moneyed interest both inside and outside the country, they might in the long run prove to be just as successful as Zimbabweans’ forced take over of white control farms have been. Of course, the ANC in it's new role as protector of moneyed interest in South Africa will be forced to make a choice. Will they side with the Black masses or with the white minority? If the Marikana mine incident where 34 Black miners were murdered in cold blood (mainly by Black South African police) for demanding better wages is any indication, land reform in South Africa will make land reform in Zimbabwe look like a lunch in the park.

    Nearly 15 years after “fast track” land reform began in Zimbabwe, we have seen the vast majority of Zimbabwe's land returned to it's rightful owners. After nearly 20 years of ANC rule in South Africa, the vast majority of South Africa's land is still in the hands of it's white minority. The controversy and criticism the ANC has sought to avoid by not pursuing a more aggressive and just land reform and economic program in the immediate post Apartheid period, will surely come back to haunt them in the post Mandela era. We shall see.

    Harold Green is a Pan-African activist based in Los Angeles. He can be contacted at


    Share this


    Hi there! I could have sworn I've been to this blog before but after browsing through some of the post I realized
    it's new to me. Anyways, I'm definitely happy I found it
    and I'll be book-marking and checking back often!
    vert Shock system

    -- [...]???????????? -

    [...]???????????? - ????????? ?????? ????????? ????????? ???????????????.[...]
    ### 칭찬합시다 - 사용안함 - 박종범 영산 회장님 많은 후원 감사드립니다!
    ...etcetera. - Catalog al afacerilor
    ::대학원 연구실 소개:: - 김윤희교수의 ë””ì§€í„¸í†µì‹ ì—°êµ¬ì‹¤ 소개
    [***] [***]
    [I Agree, Let Me Go!]
    11/3/2014 4:38
    12 Things You’re Doing Wrong on OKCupid
    2012년도 수치계산 게시판 - 수치컴퓨팅 및 응용 ìˆ™ì œ2 openGL포함 소스코드
    2013_winter mechmath - [중요] 이준상 교수님 홈페이지에서 서식 다운받으십시오.
    a podcast about sex
    ‘Pippi Longstocking’ Studio On Tami Erin Adult Picture
    adult performer Siri and International Mr. Leather follow-up
    Apsilankyti vartotojo tinklapyje
    Author\'s Website
    Bekijk de homepage
    Bekijk Webpagina
    Besøg brugerens webside
    Besøg Web siden
    Besøk innleggers hjemmeside
    Besøk Medlemmets Nettside
    Besök användarens hemsida
    Buy Real Cheap Facebook Likes
    Buy Vine Likes One Can Hire Providers To Get Help In Buying Facebook Likes
    chicago sex podcast
    chicago sex podcast -
    chicago sex podcast (not verified)
    chicago sex podcast’s avatar
    Chicago Sex Positive Podcast
    child porn
    child porn\'s Gravatar
    Clemmies Homepage besuchen
    Click here to visit this page
    Close this Frame.
    comedian and attending sex addict classes
    Content URL
    Сайт автора
    Посетить сайт автора
    Посетить Web Page автора
    Посетете сайта на потребителя
    괌여행팁 - 9ì›”10일부터 웨스틴 ìžìœ ì—¬í–‰ 상품을 이용시 ë¬´ë™ë ¥ í•´ì–‘ìŠ¤í¬ì¸ ê°€ 무료로...
    êµì œ > 사진첩 - 2014ë…„ 4ì›” 야외예배2 - 동명초등학교
    êµíšŒì¼ì • - 2013ë…„ 05ì›” 교회 주요행사 안내
    Ecampus -
    Eric Barry Chicago
    Eric Barry Chicago sex
    Eric Barry Chicago sex offender
    eric barry is gay
    Facebook\'s Black Market Problem Revealed - (4个脚印) (not verified) guy porn guy porn - guy porn (не проверено) guy porn (not verified) Says : sucks trackbacked on October 26, 2014, 11:41 am
    free porn
    free pussy
    free sex
    free xxx porn
    free xxx porn -
    free xxx porn(free xxx porn)
    Fugazi Full Disclosure Lyrics
    Full Disclosure
    Full Disclosure podcast
    Full Disclosure Podcast with Eric Barry
    Full Disclosure website
    Full Disclosure: Chicago\'s Sex Positive Podcast - Chica[...]
    Full Disclosure: Chicago\'s Sex Positive Podcast - Chicago-based podcast dedicated to sex positive news, interviews, and comedy with comedian and writer Eric Barry.
    Full Disclosure: Chicago\'s Sex Positive Podcast - Chicago-based podcast dedicated to sex positive news, interviews, and comedy with comedian and writer Eric Barry. - Backlinks on ParaKOSTer - []
    Getting Chance To Buy Facebook Likes Cheap
    Hendericks\'s homepage
    here you go
    Holy Porn Poachers - Superman! Axel Braun Shows Sues 098 Superman XXX Thieves - 7
    Home Page
    Home Page Home Page
    Homepage besuchen
    Homepage des Autors besuchen
    How Facebook Likes Get Bought And Sold
    How To Buy Facebook Likes With Cheapest Price
    How To Find Authentic Jobs Classifieds
    성경 Q&A - 대한민국 \"최초\" 프리미엄 릴 ㄱ ㅔ임 ì „ë¬¸ 싸 ã…‡ ㅣ트 릴넷
    Επίσκεψη στην ιστοσελίδα του Συγγραφέα
    한방상식 - 반만년 역사속의 민간요법이 다 과학-ì•„ëª¨ë ˆí¼ì‹œí”½ ê¸°ìˆ ì—°êµ¬ì› 한방과학팀 박준성(36) 연구원
    IL Sexual Predator
    is not accepting his apology
    Jwinpartners\' announces - [Announcement] Jwinpartner\'s 5th Anniversary
    Käy lähettäjän sivustolla
    Lesbo Retro Adult Retrospective Tonight At IXFF Film Fest In SF
    Link Anchor
    listen to the interview
    LiveCamNetwork Nets XBiz Nomination
    Longwell guy porn
    Miss Delaware Unfairly Outed By GirlsDoPorn aka Bubblegum Casting, A Shady Modeling Agency
    moment - 131125 tvN 制作发表会
    my sex-positive podcast called Full Disclosure
    Näytä web-sivu
    Naar website
    Nano-Photonics, KAIST - Baking 완료. SEM 사용재개
    notice - ★生日献礼★ 李东海29岁生日门板 3P
    انتقل الى صفحة المرسل
    صفحة الوب
    Odwied stron autora
    Odwiedź stronę autora
    ON 독서나눔방 - \'관계의 힘\'을 읽ê³
    Open website
    Página Principal
    Pastor Choi\'s Video Message - 2014.11.23 - 함께 나누며 감사하라(Thank the Lord with sharing)
    Persönliche Website von »NZachary« besuchen
    Persönliche Website von »PTVXR« besuchen
    photo - 140530 B.A.P 2014 L.O.E in Singapore Press Conference
    Podcast for young gay boys
    podcast host
    Pokaż stronę
    Positions Available - Immigration&Recruiting company looking Administrative manager
    Postati ofertele dvs. speciale aici 2009-09-28
    Pretty Emma Watson Pictures And Videos
    Read More
    Rough Sex Videos
    sex podcas
    sex podcast
    sex podcast chicago
    Sexual Openness
    Site web Site web
    Strona WWW
    Sunday Sermon - The Naming of 12 Apostles
    Teleteria has been the leader while in the
    The comments are worth reading - members of the leather community, including people who were in attendance, some of whom were working the event and dealt with Mr. Barry personally have much to say.
    Tips To Help You Buy Proper Facebook Likes
    Vaata liikme veebilehte
    Vedi la pagina Web
    Ver Página Web
    Ver Páxina Web
    Video And chatsex Chat ChatSex Shows!
    View Original
    View Web Page
    Visa WEB-sidan
    Visit Podcast Home Page
    Visit posters website
    Visit poster\'s website
    Visit Website
    Visita il mio sito
    Visita sito
    Visitar a homepage do Usuário
    Visitar a página do Utilizador
    Visitar a página na web do utilizador
    Visitar o website do usuário
    Visitar Site
    Visitar Sitio
    Visitar sitio web del autor
    Visiter la Page Web
    Visiter le site
    Visiter le site web de l\'utilisateur
    Visiter le site web du posteur
    Viziteaza site-ul autorului
    Vizitează site-ul autorului
    Vizualizare Pagina Web
    Web Site
    Weboldal megktekintése
    Website bekijken
    Website dieses Benutzers besuchen
    Webstranu posjetiti
    When Should I Buy Facebook Likes?
    Why DoN\'t You To Use A Free Webhost
    Why Schools Are BuyingXxx Web Addresses
    Why Universities Are BuyingXxx Web Addresses
    Worldwide Adult Legislation Could Boost British Sector (Wired UK)
    www.fdpod.… favicons
    xxx porn
    young teen sluts
    your company is still a business
    Zobraziť autorové WWW stránky
    Zobraziť autorove WWW stránky
    Zobrazit autorovi WWW stránky
    Zobrazit autorovy WWW stránky

    Michael Kors Outlet

    If the Michael Kors Outlet organization louis vuitton handbags canada guys Michael Kors Outlet coming from Louis Vuitton Outlet The european countries Louis Vuitton UK Outlet time for Replica Louis Vuitton UK the actual Stuart Weitzman Boots timeless Louis Vuitton Outlet Fifty-five Michael Kors Outlet chessboard Michael Kors Outlet cup of tea Michael Kors Canada Outlet as being a Michael Kors Sale present Michael Kors Handbags for Michael By Michael Kors Handbags wife, Michael Kors Crossbody Outlet frequently Michael Kors Handbags Australia though Michael Kors Australia being Michael Kors Canada left behind, MK handbags Outlet women Louis Vuitton Canada Sale will Authentic Jordan shoes feel Stuart Weitzman 5050 no Louis Vuitton Canada Free Shipping perception Michael Kors Handbags Outlet of Michael Kors Canada Sale mannerCheap Michael Kors or Michael Kors Online smash Wholesale Michael Kors Handbags Outlet this Clutches section Cheap Michael Kors Crossbody Bags an excessive amount. Cheap Michael Kors Handbags Any Michael Kors Bags Australia incorporates a Michael Kors In Australia quantity of Michael Kors Australia Stockists 55 Where to buy michael kors in australia? baggage, Michael Kors Outlet Online garment Michael Kors Sale Multiple- Replica LV Outlet Nationwide Louis Vuitton UK Cheap Firm louis vuitton sale Chinese language Louis Vuitton Canada Section Cheap Louis Vuitton Handbags Sale girls in-between Michael Kors Australia Bags furthermore Wholesale Michael Kors Bags informed this particular michael kors handbags online newsman Discount Michael Kors lamented, " Michael Kors Bags online currently 55 Cheap Louis Vuitton Canada Outlet is among the most authentic jordan shoes for sale common workers Air Jordans sale perhaps stuart weitzman 5050 childcare professional Louis Vuitton uk also can Michael Kors Handbags Online have the funds for to acquire the actual brand,

    Why so many lives lost in Matabeleland in the 1980s?

    Whilst I have no wish to side with the New World Order against a person who is being villified by the mainstream media, I would be interested to know how Robert Mugabe's actions in Matableland in the 1980s are consistent with the view that he liberated Zimbabwe.

    At least many thousands died in that conflict. It has been labeled 'genocide' by a number of sources, not all of which can be easily dismissed as mouthpieces of the global elites :


    Also, you may find <em><a href="">"Mandela: Shock Doctrine on how the African Revolution was hijacked by bankers"</a></em>, of 7 Dec 2013, of interest. As the title suggests, it cites Naomi Klein's "The Shock Doctrine" of 2007.