Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.  If you broadcast our audio commentaries please consider a recurring donation to Black Agenda Report.

Letter to Obama: America’s Selective Memory and the Cuban Five

  • Sharebar
    Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version

    by Piero Gleijeses

    Washington’s selective memory of Cuba’s role in the world – and America’s own sordid past and present – prevents its leaders from seeing reality clearly. But President Obama witnessed first hand that Africa remembers who its friends are. “While the Cubans were fighting for the liberation of the people of South Africa, successive American governments did everything they could to stop them.”

    Letter to Obama: America’s Selective Memory and the Cuban Five

    by Piero Gleijeses

    “You witnessed how warmly the South African people responded to Raúl Castro.”

    February 5, 2014

    Mr. President,

    I will not address the juridical flaws of the case against the Cuban Five. These flaws are well known and others have written you about them. The Five were tried in a kangaroo court and received very heavy sentences because of the crimes of Fidel Castro.

    What are these crimes? 

    Clearly, they have nothing to do with the state of political democracy in Cuba. The United States has very good relations with the government of Saudi Arabia and, as you know, there are no political freedoms there; indeed, there isn't even freedom of religion and the rights of women are severely curtailed.

    Castro's crime – for which the Five are paying – is obvious: he humiliated the United States. As Leycester Coltman, a British ambassador to Cuba, has written, Fidel Castro is "still a bone . . . stuck in American throats. He had defied and mocked the world's only superpower, and would not be forgiven."[1]

    Where did the Castro brothers defy the United States?  One of the most important places is southern Africa.  I am sure you sensed this in your recent visit to South Africa when you witnessed how warmly the South African people responded to Raúl Castro.  As the chair of the African National Congress said, when introducing Raúl Castro, "We now will get an address from a tiny island, an island of people who liberated us, who fought for our liberation." 

    While the Cubans were fighting for the liberation of the people of South Africa, successive American governments did everything they could to stop them.

    In October 1975, the South Africans, encouraged by the Ford administration, invaded Angola to crush the left wing Popular Movement for the Liberation of Angola (MPLA). In response, 36,000 Cuban soldiers suddenly poured into Angola.  By April 1976, the Cuban troops had pushed the South Africans out.

    Had the South Africans succeeded in imposing their will on Angola, the grip of white domination would have tightened over the people of southern Africa.  It was a defining moment: Castro sent troops to Angola because of his commitment to what he has called "the most beautiful cause,"[2] the struggle against apartheid. Castro, Kissinger explained, "was probably the most genuine revolutionary leader then in power."[3]

    The tidal wave unleashed by the Cuban victory in Angola washed over South Africa.  Mandela later recalled hearing about it while he was incarcerated on Robben Island. "I was in prison when I first heard of the massive aid that the internationalist Cuban troops were giving to the people of Angola. ... We in Africa are accustomed to being the victims of countries that want to grab our territory or subvert our sovereignty.  In all the history of Africa this is the only time a foreign people has risen up to defend one of our countries."[4]

    “The tidal wave unleashed by the Cuban victory in Angola washed over South Africa.”

    This Cuban victory over apartheid meant a defeat and a humiliation for the United States. Enraged, the Ford administration ended the talks it had been conducting with Cuba toward normalizing relations.

    President Carter also said there could be no normalization of relations until Cuba withdrew its troops from Angola – even though the CIA conceded that the Cuban troops were "necessary to preserve Angolan independence" against the continuing threat posed by South Africa.[5] In June 1980, the South Africans launched another major raid, advancing more than a hundred miles into Angola, stopping only thirty miles south of the Cuban line protecting the country.  The UN Security Council responded with a tough resolution condemning the invasion, and the US representative on the Council minced no words in his speech chastising South Africa. When it came to vote, however, he abstained because the resolution included language suggesting that if South Africa launched another attack on Angola the Security Council might impose sanctions.

    I am sure you can appreciate the irony, Mr. President.  The United States had stationed large numbers of troops in Italy, West Germany and Turkey - countries that faced no immediate military threat from the Soviet Union in 1980, but Jimmy Carter denied the Angolans the right to have Cuban troops to protect their country from the very real South African threat.

    Castro refused to bow to Carter's demands, which meant that he sacrificed the possibility of normalization with the United States (and the lifting of the embargo) in order to protect Angola from the apartheid regime.

    From 1981 to 1987, the South Africans launched bruising invasions of southern Angola, encouraged by the friendly Reagan administration in Washington. It was a stalemate until November 1987, when Castro decided to push the South Africans out of Angola once and for all.  His decision was triggered by the fact that the South African army had cornered the best units of the Angolan army in the southern Angolan town of Cuito Cuanavale.  And his decision was made possible by the Iran Contra scandal rocking Washington.  Until the Iran Contra scandal exploded in late 1986, weakening and distracting the Reagan administration, the Cubans had feared that the United States might launch an attack on their homeland.  They had therefore been unwilling to deplete their stocks of weapons.  But Iran Contra defanged Reagan and freed Castro to send Cuba's best planes, pilots, and antiaircraft weapons to Angola. Castro's strategy was to break the South African offensive against Cuito Cuanavale in the southeast and then attack in the southwest, "like a boxer who with his left hand blocks the blow and with his right - strikes."[6]

    On March 23, 1988, the South Africans launched their last major attack against Cuito Cuanavale. It was an abject failure. The US Joint Chiefs of Staff  noted, "The war in Angola has taken a dramatic and -- as far as the South Africans are concerned -- an undesirable turn."[7]

    The Cubans' left hand had blocked the South African blow while their right hand was preparing to strike: powerful Cuban columns were moving towards the Namibian border, pushing the South Africans back. Cuban MIG-23s began to fly over northern Namibia.

    “Iran Contra defanged Reagan and freed Castro to send Cuba's best planes, pilots, and antiaircraft weapons to Angola.”

    Among the Cuban soldiers advancing toward the Namibian border were two young men whose names are now well known: Fernando González Llort and Gerardo Hernández Nordelo. Ten years earlier, René González Sehwerert had also fought in Angola.  These three men, together with Ramón Labañino Salazar and Antonio Guerrero Rodríguez, are the five Cubans on whose behalf I am writing.

    US and South African documents prove that the Cubans gained the upper hand in Angola. The Cubans demanded that Pretoria withdraw unconditionally from Angola and allow UN-supervised elections in Namibia. The US Joint Chiefs of Staff warned that if South Africa refused, the Cubans were in a position "to launch a well-supported offensive into Namibia." The South Africans acknowledged their dilemma: if they refused the Cuban demands, they ran "the very real risk of becoming involved in a full-scale conventional war with the Cubans, the results of which are potentially disastrous." The South African military was grim: "We must do the utmost to avoid a confrontation."[8]

    Pretoria capitulated.  It accepted the Cubans' demands: it withdrew unconditionally from Angola and agreed to UN-supervised elections in Namibia.

    The Cuban victory reverberated beyond Namibia and Angola. In the words of Nelson Mandela, the Cuban victory "destroyed the myth of the invincibility of the white oppressor ... [and] inspired the fighting masses of South Africa ... Cuito Cuanavale was the turning point for the liberation of our continent - and of my people - from the scourge of apartheid."[9]

    You were at Mandela's memorial service, Mr. President, and you celebrated his legacy. You saw the reaction of the South African people to Raúl Castro and to the name of Cuba. Yes, Cuba changed the course of history in southern Africa despite Washington's best efforts to prevent it. In so doing Cuba offended and provoked the United States - not only Ford, and Reagan but also Carter, self-styled champion of human rights. In the American mind, Cuba was the aggressor and the United States was, as always, on the side of the angels. As US historian Nancy Mitchell has pointed out, "our selective recall not only serves a purpose, it also has repercussions. It creates a chasm between us and the Cubans: we share a past, but we have no shared memories."[10]

    Perhaps, Mr. President, what you saw in South Africa may inspire you to bridge the chasm and understand that in the quarrel between Cuba and the United States the United States is not the victim, and that the Five Cubans are, simply, political prisoners. 

     

    Piero Gleijeses 

     

    Piero Gleijeses is a professor of US foreign policy at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies. His most recent book is Visions of Freedom: Havana, Washington, Pretoria and the Struggle for Southern Africa, 1976-1991, Chapel Hill, 2013.  His other books include The Cuban Drumbeat: Castro's Worldview, Seagull Books, 2009; Conflicting Missions: Havana, Washington and Africa, 1959-1976. Chapel Hill, 2002; Shattered Hope: The Guatemalan Revolution and the United States, 1944-1954, Princeton, 1992; The Dominican Crisis: The 1965 Constitutionalist Revolt and American Intervention. Baltimore, 1978 (revised edition: La esperanza desgarrada: la rebelión dominicana de 1965 y la invasión norteamericana, Dominican Republic, 2012).

     

    [1] Leycester Coltman, The Real Fidel Castro, New Haven, 2003, p. 289.

    [2]  "Indicaciones concretas del Comandante en Jefe que guiarán la actuación de la delegación cubana a las conversaciones en Luanda y las negociaciones en Londres (23-4-88)," p. 5, Centro de Información de las Fuerzas Armadas Revolucionarias, Havana.

    [3] Henry Kissinger, Years of Renewal, New York, 1999, p.785.

    [4] Mandela, 26 July 1991, Granma (Havana), 27 July 1991, p. 3.

    [5]  CIA, "Angola Cuba: Some Strains but No New Developments," 9 Apr. 1979, Central Intelligence Agency Records Search Tool, National Archives, College Park, MD.

    [6] Memcon (Fidel Castro, Joe Slovo et al.), 29 Sept. 1988, p. 16, Centro de Información de las Fuerzas Armadas Revolucionarias, Havana.

    [7] US Joint Chiefs of Staff, 15 Apr. 1988, National Security Archive, Washington DC.

    [8] US Joint Chiefs of Staff, 28 July 1988, ibid.; Mike Malone to A. Jacquet, enclosed in Jacquet to Pik Botha, 20 July 1988, SWA/Angola, v. 2, Department of Foreign Affairs, Pretoria; General Jannie Geldenhuys,  "Samevatting van notas mbt SAW-operasies in Suid-Angola," 23 Aug. 1988, H SAW, gr. 4, box 160, Department of Defence, Documentation Centre, Pretoria.

    [9]  Mandela, 26 July 1991, Granma, 27 July 1991, p. 3.

    [10] Nancy Mitchell, "Remember the Myth," News and Observer (Raleigh), 1 Nov. 1998, G5.

    Share this

    It is great to have the

    It is great to have the opportunity to read a good quality article with useful information on topics that plenty are interested on.I concur with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your future updates.Thomas and Friends Seasons 1-4 DVD Box Set uk | Boardwalk Empire Seasons 1-3 DVD Box Set UK | Project Runway Seasons 12 DVD Box Set uk | Everybody Hates Chris seasons 1-4 DVD box set UK | The Mentalist Seasons 1-5 DVD Box set uk | MI-5 Spooks Seasons 1-9 DVD Box Set UK

    You have a very inspiring way

    You have a very inspiring way of exploring and sharing your thoughts. It is very uncommon nowadays, lots of sites and blogs having copy pasted or rewritten info. But here, no doubt, info is original and very well structured. Keep it up. !!Strike Back Seasons 1-3 DVD Box Set | The Best Of Soul Train DVD Box Set | Leverage Seasons 1-5 DVD Box Set | Boston Legal Seasons 1-5 DVD Boxset | Battlestar Galactica Seasons 1-4 DVD Boxset

    Clicky Web Analytics