Expect “Massive Resistance” to Stop-and-Frisk Ruling

by BAR executive editor Glen Ford

A federal court ruling against New York City’s stop-and-frisk practices says, essentially: “There are to be no ‘Constitution-free zones’” where Blacks can be treated as lesser citizens. However, the entire American political establishment is committed to racial surveillance and mass Black incarceration. That’s why “the ruling will be met with massive resistance reminiscent of the official southern white reaction to the 1954 U.S. Supreme Court school desegregation decision.”

 

Expect “Massive Resistance” to Stop-and-Frisk Ruling

by BAR executive editor Glen Ford

There is no basis for assuming that an innocent population shares the same characteristics as the criminal suspect population in the same area.”

On February 4, 1999, four plainclothes New York City police officers summarily executed Amadou Diallo in a barrage of 41 bullets, setting in motion a legal battle that challenged the constitutionality of the city’s stop-and-frisk policies. Last week, federal judge Shira Scheindlin ruled in favor of the Black and Latino plaintiffs in a class action suit, declaring that New York’s stop-and-frisk policies amount to racially selective violations of the Constitution’s prohibitions against unreasonable searches. In her 195-page decision, Scheindlin noted that more Blacks and Latinos have been accosted by police on the streets of New York since 2004 than actually live in city. Stop-and-frisk, as practiced by the NYPD, is designed to “instill fear” in the targeted groups, said the judge, and “there is a sufficient basis for inferring discriminatory intent.” Scheindlin ordered that:

* an independent monitor, accountable to the courts, oversee stop-and-frisk activities;

* police supervisors cease enforcing a “quota” system that compels officers to make unwarranted stops;

* cops in selected precincts wear video cameras, to record their actual behavior in confronting citizens on the street; and,

* establishment of a Joint Remedial Process, in which community residents in high-volume-stops neighborhoods would make their opinions and proposals known.

It should be expected that the ruling will be met with massive resistance reminiscent of the official southern white reaction to the 1954 U.S. Supreme Court school desegregation decision. Mayor Michael Bloomberg greeted the ruling with defiance equal to that of Alabama Governor George Wallace’s threats to stand in the schoolhouse door. “You’re not going to see any change in tactics overnight,” said the billionaire politician, whose term ends next year. Bloomberg will immediately appeal the ruling, which could then be put on hold pending the outcome.

More Blacks and Latinos have been accosted by police on the streets of New York since 2004 than actually live in city.”

Bloomberg and his police commissioner, Ray Kelly, have comported themselves with such brazen racial arrogance as to welcome a grand confrontation with the court – in much the same manner as white officialdom behaved in Dixie in the Fifties and early Sixties. Back in June, amidst voluminous court testimony on wildly disproportionate police stops of young Black and brown men, the mayor told listeners to his weekly radio show: “I think we disproportionately stop whites too much and minorities too little. It's exactly the reverse of what they say.”

The dignity of whites, who make up only nine percent of those stopped, is precious, while the rights of Blacks are of no consequence to the mayor. Commissioner Kelly has been Bloomberg’s enforcer of race-based law during the whole period scrutinized by Judge Scheindlin. Kelly admitted to a Black state senator and retired police captain that the purpose of stop-and-frisk was to “instill fear” among Black and Latino men that they would be stopped and frisked whenever they left their homes – a quote cited by the judge.

Bloomberg and Kelly have good reason to relish a throw-down, since the ideological foundations of their policing positions are shared by most whites (60 percent of white New Yorkers support stop-and-frisk) and by federal law enforcement – albeit in stealth fashion, under President Obama and Attorney General Eric Holder. Kelly, whose reputation is inextricably entwined with stop-and-frisk, was under serious consideration as the next head of Homeland Security. “I think Ray Kelly is one of the best there is,” said President Obama, “so he’s been an outstanding leader in New York.”

The purpose of stop-and-frisk was to ‘instill fear’ among Black and Latino men.”

Eric Holder, whose sins of mass Black incarceration are legion, claims to welcome the appointment of a federal monitor over the NYPD. Fortunately, the monitor would be answerable to the court, not Holder’s office. The nation’s first Black top law enforcement officer has allowed his U.S. attorney in Indianapolis to conduct selective enforcement of gun laws limited to five “hot zones” – neighborhoods that just happen to include much of the city’s Black population. This goes to the actual, geographic and racial heart of stop-and-frisk, which is not directed against individual Black and brown men, but against their racial groups and, primarily, the neighborhoods they live in. Holder allows the U.S. attorney in Indianapolis to redline whole Black neighborhoods for selective federal gun law enforcement – he explicitly promised to confine the practice to the designated “hot zones” – because that is consistent with Obama administration policy. Remember that Obama, in his post-Zimmerman acquittal reminiscences of his days as a profiled Black youth, attempted to frame Trayvon Martin’s killing as essentially a “gun crime.” The administration wishes to convert Black rage at the summary execution of African Americans by law enforcement and various vigilantes into acceptance of racially selective “gun control” – a stance that is entirely consistent with Bloomberg and Kelly’s rationale for stop-and-frisk as a gun control practice (despite the fact that only two percent of NYPD stops uncover weapons of any kind).

A key part of Judge Scheindlin’s ruling deals directly with the issue of the geography of policing. In rejecting the city’s argument that disproportionate stop-and-frisks are necessary because Blacks and Latinos commit disproportionate numbers of crimes, the judge applied the principles of the Constitution’s 4th and 14th Amendments. Police need to provide “individualized proof” that a given person on a given street at a given time, exhibiting specific and reasonably understood behaviors, should be stopped and frisked. Arithmetic on the gross number of crimes in an area won’t do.

The administration wishes to convert Black rage at the summary execution of African Americans by law enforcement and various vigilantes into acceptance of racially selective ‘gun control.’”

"There is no basis for assuming,” wrote Scheindlin, “that an innocent population shares the same characteristics as the criminal suspect population in the same area. Instead, I conclude that the benchmark used by plaintiffs’ expert — a combination of local population demographics and local crime rates (to account for police deployment)—is the most sensible."

That means no stops in “hot zones” or “designated drug zones” or “high crime neighborhoods” without “individualized proof” – although crime statistics can and should be used in terms of the deployment of police. There are to be no “Constitution-free zones.”

Neither Bloomberg nor Obama are willing to live within the bounds of the law, as interpreted by Scheindlin. Effectively, they are allied in maintaining a hyper-surveillance regime for Blacks, the foundation of mass Black incarceration. (Obama, of course, has much larger plans in progress, for the whole nation and planet.)

The Center for Constitutional Rights must be applauded for waging such a critical legal battle all these years. The NAACP Legal Defense Fund is also to be commended for its suit against horrific police abuse of public housing tenants, which goes to trial in October. However, legal strategies are highly vulnerable to determined institutional resistance, and the passage of time. The white South’s massive resistance to school desegregation was, for a time, successful in holding the color line – until Blacks physically challenged American apartheid, bringing the crisis to a head. The so-called New Jim Crow (Judge Scheindlin cited the book), which has imposed its dominion of mass Black surveillance and incarceration over the course of two generations, is national in scope, bipartisan in nature, and supported by majorities of whites. It will not be defeated in a courtroom.

Carl Dix, of Stop Stop-and-Frisk, who, along with activist academic Dr. Cornel West launched a direct action campaign to confront the NYPD, asks: “Why should we expect a federal monitor to end the way Blacks and Latinos are mistreated by the NYPD, when the Department of Justice is fighting people sentenced under the 100-1 sentencing disparity for crack cocaine possession who are trying to get those sentences reduced?”

Only a grassroots people’s movement can defend African American rights to live as dignified, self-determining human beings. Bloomberg can’t appeal the verdict of the streets.

BAR executive editor Glen Ford can be contacted at Glen.Ford@BlackAgendaReport.com.

37 Comments

Ik ben het volledig eens met

Ik ben het volledig eens met die post. Ze moeten de criminaliteit te stoppen! TI delen zeker mijn gedachten met mijn whatsapp messenger.

Re: well

The world is changing fast. people are also being changed.day by day we are becoming more dependant on degital system.yoU make me think of this really.You have a nice way of sharing your thoughts. High Pagerank Backlinks
Buy Backlinks

Awesome

There is no basis for assuming,” wrote Scheindlin, “that an innocent population shares the same characteristics as the criminal suspect population in the same area. Instead, I conclude that the benchmark used by plaintiffs’ expert — a combination of local population demographics and local crime rates (to account for police deployment)—is the most sensible. forex gold

Awesome

Excellent read, Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work. Educational Supplies

Cellex-C

Also, from one anchovy to another, the strong, distinctly flavored food metaphor is one close to my heart. I've been calling myself Stilton for a long time: appealing to a limited audience, but that audience are loyal fans. Cellex-C

preschool math

As a young boy, athletics was Mr. Lonardelli’s outlet for success. Mr. Lonardelli excelled in several extra-curricular athletic programs which presented him with several scholarship opportunities to which Mr. Lonardelli accepted a scholarship to the University of Winnipeg. preschool math

Buckle Credit Card

Born in London, England, Dr. Desai gained a Pharmacy degree in 1981, a PhD in 1985 and an MBA in 1993. He has spent close to 30 years in progressively senior positions in the pharmaceutical industry. Buckle Credit Card

Do you know that....

People infected by chilly trojans spread the ailment once they shhh or sneeze. Shhh or maybe sneezing causes the infected human being to help splutter saliva and sweaty fluid known as mucous. This kind of fluid has the pain medication. While microscopic degrees of this fluid pollute the environment, including the air or perhaps personal things like towels or maybe handkerchiefs, folks who come across these individuals become at risk of chlamydia. The herpes virus becomes given through the fresh air we inhale or as a result of each of our grubby hands when we contact our own noses.

Aktien

I love it when things get improved, thanks for putting up a great guide. Hope it will help me out in my future projects Aktien

Kindergarten

Ray Ban Outlet sunglasses have appeared in thousands of movies and have been a staple of Hollywood fashion for decades. Iconic styles like the Aviator, Wayfarer, and Clubmaster reflect the rich heritage and timeless style that changed the world of eyewear forever. Kindergarten

ideas bathroom

Even though there are many keyword research tools out there, all of them are not created equal. This is why you need to be extremely cautious and conduct extensive research before selecting the best keyword research tool out there. ideas bathroom

You might write about the

You might write about the uniqueness on the blog. You should formulate it's necessary. Your blog explanation might grow your co-ops. Commenting

Opponents of the Brown ruling

Opponents of the Brown ruling and integration used the doctrine of interposition, which argued that the state could "interpose" between an unconstitutional federal mandate and local authorities based on State Sovereignty. The General Assembly adopted a resolution of interposition in 1956 that clearly defied the authority of the federal courts. James Jackson Kilpatrick, editor of the Richmond News Leader, vigorously criticized the court decisions to end segregation and was one of the leading public advocates of interposition. Bike Rack For Garage

Michael Kors Outlet

If the Michael Kors Canada company louis vuitton handbags canada guys Michael Kors Outlet coming from Louis Vuitton Outlet The european countries Louis Vuitton UK Outlet to Replica Louis Vuitton UK the Stuart Weitzman Boots traditional Louis Vuitton Outlet Fifty-five Michael Kors Outlet chessboard Michael Kors Outlet bag Michael Kors Canada Outlet as being a Michael Kors Sale giving Michael Kors Handbags with regards to Michael By Michael Kors Handbags married woman, Michael Kors Crossbody Outlet typically Michael Kors Handbags Australia even though Michael Kors Australia organism Michael Kors Canada derelict, MK Canada Outlet women Louis Vuitton Canada Sale will certainly Authentic Jordan shoes tactile property Stuart Weitzman 5050 absolutely no Louis Vuitton Bags Outlet good sense Michael Kors Canada Outlet connected with Cheap Michael Kors Handbags Online modeCheap Michael Kors or Michael Kors Outlet Sale reach Wholesale Michael Kors Handbags Sale the actual Clutches sentence Cheap Michael Kors Crossbody Bags an excessive amount of. Cheap Michael Kors Handbags A new Michael Kors Bags Australia incorporates a Michael Kors In Australia variety of Michael Kors Australia Stockists Fifty-five Where to buy michael kors in australia? hand bags, Michael Kors Outlet Online clothe Michael Kors Sale Multiple- Replica Louis Vuitton Handbags UK Home(a) Louis Vuitton UK Handbags Firm louis vuitton outlet Far east Louis Vuitton Sale District Cheap Louis Vuitton Outlet Sale women of all ages http://www.comt.ca/default.html in-between Michael Kors Australia Store additionally Wholesale Michael Kors Australia told http://www.itxperts.com.au/flash/ this particular michael kors handbags shop reporter Discount Michael Kors lamented, " mk Bags online today http://www.himag.co.uk/uk.asp Fifty-five Cheap Louis Vuitton Outlet is among the most cheap jordan shoes for sale ordinary http://www.browniesautocarecenter.com/handbags.php staff members Air Jordans sale also stuart weitzman 5050 nanny Louis Vuitton uk also can Michael Kors Handbags Online yield to purchase your brand name,

Michael Kors Outlet

In the event the Michael Kors Canada company louis vuitton handbags canada men Michael Kors Outlet through Louis Vuitton Outlet European union Louis Vuitton UK Outlet back to Replica Louis Vuitton UK the particular Stuart Weitzman Boots traditional Louis Vuitton Outlet 55 Michael Kors Outlet chessboard Michael Kors Outlet cup of tea Michael Kors Canada Outlet being a Michael Kors Sale treat Michael Kors Handbags for Michael By Michael Kors Handbags better half, Michael Kors Crossbody Outlet generally Michael Kors Handbags Australia although Michael Kors Australia getting Michael Kors Canada deserted, Michael Kors bags Outlet ladies Louis Vuitton Canada Sale will probably Authentic Jordan shoes experience Stuart Weitzman 5050 zero Louis Vuitton Bags Free Shipping impression Michael Kors Canada Outlet regarding Cheap Michael Kors Handbags Outlet mannerCheap Michael Kors or even Michael Kors Online struck Wholesale Michael Kors Handbags Outlet the particular Accessories piece Cheap Michael Kors Crossbody Bags a lot of. Cheap Michael Kors Handbags The Michael Kors Bags Australia includes a Michael Kors In Australia quantity of Michael Kors Australia Stockists 55 Where to buy michael kors in australia? baggage, Michael Kors Outlet Online dress Michael Kors Sale Multi- Replica Louis Vuitton Handbags UK Home(a) Louis Vuitton UK Cheap Company louis vuitton outlet Chinese language LV Online Territory Cheap Louis Vuitton Outlet UK girls http://www.comt.ca/default.html center Michael Kors Australia Store furthermore Wholesale Michael Kors Australia informed http://www.itxperts.com.au/flash/ this particular michael kors handbags australia news reporter Discount Michael Kors complained, " Michael Kors Black Friday online nowadays http://www.himag.co.uk/uk.asp 55 Cheap Louis Vuitton Canada Outlet is among the most cheap jordans for sale common http://www.browniesautocarecenter.com/handbags.php employees Air Jordans sale even stuart weitzman 5050 nurse Louis Vuitton uk can also Michael Kors Handbags Online have the funds for to get the brand,

political establishment is

political establishment is committed to racial surveillance and mass Black incarceration. That’s why “the ruling will be met with massive resistance reminiscent of the official southern white reaction to the 1954 U.S. Supreme Court school desegregation decisionsmarttraveller

Judi Poker Uang Asli

I'm searching forward for more supportive articles from you.thanks for imparting the thought there would be a few misgivings from portion yet i am up for it. Judi Poker Uang Asli