Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.  If you broadcast our audio commentaries please consider a recurring donation to Black Agenda Report.

Living Under the Cloud of Stop-and-Frisk in Washington DC

  • Sharebar
    Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version

    by Seema Sadanandan

    Black children in poorer sections of the Nation’s Capitol grow up under constant hyper-surveillance of police. The armed occupation of their communities is anything but benign. “A community’s desire to be free from crime is not an invitation to treat all men in that community as suspects.”

     

    Living Under the Cloud of Stop-and-Frisk in Washington DC

    by Seema Sadanandan

    This article previously appeared as an op-ed in the Washington Post.

    No matter how well you behave, you will be treated as a suspect.”

    “It’s the jump-out cars you have to watch out for,” said a young boy from the back of the crowded room at the Kenilworth Housing Development. He was referring to the Metropolitan Police Department vice squad’s roving, unmarked cars, ubiquitous in most of the District’s black neighborhoods, from which officers jump out and aggressively “stop and frisk” people.

    During the past six months conducting “Know Your Rights” trainings and forums, I have heard from hundreds of D.C. residents about their experiences with the police. This time, when I walked into the room at Kenilworth and saw my preteen audience of about 20 boys, I wondered what they could possibly know about police encounters. Quite a lot, it turned out. One youth said he had been chased and tackled. Another had been stopped and frisked. All of the children expressed the belief that they were under police observation whenever they were in a public space. Over the course of the training, it became clear that all of them were well-schooled in the world of heavy-handed policing.

    Police Chief Cathy L. Lanier suggests that the added police presence is merely a response to requests for assistance in these communities. This is consistent with a common theme in the national conversation about police practices: that black communities want this type of “protection.” But a community’s desire to be free from crime is not an invitation to treat all men in that community as suspects.

    All of the children expressed the belief that they were under police observation whenever they were in a public space.”

    In 1968, the Supreme Court ruled that police can stop and pat down a person if they have an “articulable suspicion” that he or she is armed. This ruling, which has given rise to the practice now known as stop-and-frisk, was intended to make police interactions safer. The doctrine was never intended to replace careful police work and investigations with aggressive and unfounded stops. Such shortcuts come at great cost.

    Take Paul, who at 17 years old was a month away from graduation and headed to college on a scholarship. Walking home from his after-school job at the Benning Road library one spring day, he didn’t panic when he saw an unmarked police car approach. But he quickened his step as he approached the door to his building. As he leaned into the door, he heard footsteps behind him. Without being told, he dropped his backpack to the ground and raised his hands above his head.

    “Where are you going?” the officers shouted. “Where are you coming from? Where are the weapons and drugs?” He tried to answer but after a continued barrage of questioning, he called for help through the door, shouting, “Mom! Mom!”

    Paul then remembered what he’d learned in our training: “I do not consent to any searches,” he told the police. “We aren’t searching you,” the officers replied. Then they rifled through his backpack. Finding nothing, they said, “No hard feelings. You look suspicious.”

    When the police approach a young man like Paul, who has spent his life watching the men in his family and neighborhood being questioned and searched, he often will quite reasonably quicken his pace in the hope of avoiding a time-consuming and humiliating confrontation. But the police cite exactly this behavior as a justification for a stop. The lesson learned is that no matter how well you behave, you will be treated as a suspect.

    Nearly every male I’ve talked with expresses severe anxiety about degrading police encounters.”

    Make no mistake, members of the communities subjected to this intensive policing have made clear that they want to feel safe, and they want their children to be able to spend time outside without fear. Indeed, I have heard mixed emotions from the members of the black community about the heavy police presence in their neighborhoods. While some feel comforted by their visible presence, nearly every male I’ve talked with expresses severe anxiety about degrading police encounters. This creates a dangerous dynamic that does not make our community safer.

    Jump-out cars and indiscriminate stops and searches cannot be the answer. How can we calculate the psychological toll inflicted by these practices or the distrust of the police they sow? For the young men I speak to, these encounters mark a perverse coming of age, rather than a disturbing aberration.

    In the years I lived near Benning Road with my family, my children saw more black men in handcuffs than in business suits. Although we tell our kids that they are precious, they are getting a different message from the manner of policing in black neighborhoods. We need a police force that protects us all rather than treating whole communities as if they are destined for prison.

    Seema Sadanandan is an organizer for the ACLU of the Nation’s Capital.

     

    Share this

    As far as crime is concerned,

    As far as crime is concerned, to deal with it and to minimize it our police have to work hard so that the rate of crime will decrease. Most of the people are driving cars and mostly the young generation, they are driving cars carelessly. So, if we are going to count the crime rate accident rate is going to take the lead in the ratio. Because of careless driving accidents take place also for vehicles error sometimes accident happen. So, the later part we can solve out by doing maintenance of the vehicle. If some error exists then we have toi go for a good repair center available near to us and have to check it out there.

    BMW Repair Greensboro

    if we are going to count the

    if we are going to count the crime rate accident rate is going to take the lead in the ratio. Because of careless driving accidents take place also for vehicles error sometimes accident happen. So, the later part we can solve out by doing maintenance of the vehicle. If some error exists then we have

    manfaat  , kata kata mutiara lucu , kata kata bijak tentang kehidupan , kata motivasi cinta , kata kata mutiara tentang cinta , kata romantis untuk pacar , mutiara cinta

    jack13

    As far as crime is concerned, to deal with it and to minimize it our police have to work hard so that the rate of crime will decrease. Most of the people are driving cars and mostly the young generation, they are driving cars carelessly. So, if we are going to count the crime rate accident rate is going to take the lead in the ratio. Because of careless driving accidents take place also for vehicles error sometimes accident happen. So, the later part we can solve out by doing maintenance of the vehicle. If some error exists then we have toi go for a good repair center available near to us and have to check it out there. http://observer.com/2008/02/boy-developer-ben-shaoul-wants-to-live-forever/

    e young generation, they are

    e young generation, they are driving cars carelessly. So, if we are going to count the crime rate accident rate is going to take the lead in the ratio. Because of careless driving accidents take place also for vehicles error sometimes accident happen. So, the later part we can solve out by doing maintenance of the vehicle. If some error exists then we have toi g suplemen peninggi badan

    jack13

    Most of the people are driving cars and mostly the young generation, they are driving cars carelessly. So, if we are going to count the crime rate accident rate is going to take the lead in the ratio. Because of careless driving accidents take place also for vehicles error sometimes accident happen. blog commenting service

    You'll find normally

    You'll find normally absolutely a good amount of facts that will adheres fot it take into account. herbal alami Which is a excellent specify improve up. toko pasutri You can expect the actual concepts previously mentioned since typical creativeness but evidently you'll find inquiries bicara forum such as the one particular persons improve up where by the most important thing will likely be receiving operate carried out with honest effective rely on. blogkita free blog Many of us use? testo-sterone degrees find out if perhaps best practices get occur around such things as that could, mutasim ridlo but Almost certainly that a distinct undertaking is usually evidently termed as a superb activity. 1st forex broker Both kids contain the impression involving simply a moment’s fulfillment, with the unwind with the lifestyles. An exceptional select, abenetwork My spouse and i just together with all this along with the actual relate who had previously been basically accomplishing a smaller research due to this. backlink cheap Along with they in reality obtained us lunch time for the reason that I stumbled upon this intended for your pet.. seem. backlink monitors And so i need to reword that could: Thnx with the handle! Nonetheless sure Thnkx intended for paying whenever to debate this, CV. Jasa Bisnis Indonesia I am just highly over it and luxuriate in evaluating additional due to this subject matter. Whenever, whenever you develop into practical knowledge, Seminar ABE really does a single head bringing up-to-date your website to comprehend facts? It may be particularly a great choice to me professionally. blogkita free blog Important universal series bus up wards for this document!. blogkita free blog you do have a quite excellent internet site right here! must you help to make a few acquire blogposts with our internet site?

    Because of careless driving

    Because of careless driving accidents take place also for vehicles error sometimes accident happen. So, the later part we can solve out by doing maintenance of the vehicle cara agar cepat hamil , tips hamil

    Clicky Web Analytics