Skip to Content

Obama Ordering States to Close 5,000 'Failing' Schools!... Chicago Lies Go National

by George Schmidtarne bites his tongue

The corporate narrative that public schools in minority neighborhoods are "failing" and must be replaced by unaccountable but often highly profitable "charter schools" is an inheritance from the Bush era that the Obama administration intends to continue and intensify.  Despite any proof of improved educational outcomes, and contrary to the democratic wishes of the American people the push to discredit and privatize public education appears to be a hallmark of the Obama era.



Obama Ordering States to Close 5,000 'Failing' Schools!... Chicago Lies Go National

by George Schmidt

This article was originally published in the print edition of Substance, May 2009.

Using language that most of the United States has not yet heard, but which will become familiar to democratically elected school boards from rural Maine to the Mexican border south of San Diego and El Paso, President Barack Obama's Secretary of Education, former Chicago schools Chief Executive Officer Arne Duncan, launched a national campaign in May 2009 to privatize between five and ten percent of the remaining public schools in the USA.
Under the headline "Obama Wants to See 5,000 Failing Schools Close," Associated Press reporter Libby Quaid released a three-paragraph story on May 11 that rocked the nation.
"Barack Obama wants to see 5,000 failing schools close and reopen with new principals and teachers over the next five years," the AP reported.
"Education Secretary Arne Duncan says kids have only one shot at a good education. He told The Associated Press on Monday that chronically underperforming schools need a new start," the story went on.
STOP: As Chicagoans know, and the rest of the USA is about to learn, when a Chicago politicians talks about "underperforming" schools, he is slipping into that weasel wording that Chicago came to know from Arne Duncan. Just as he did in Chicago, Duncan talked about "underperforming" schools — not "failing" ones. Why? Because Duncan wanted to obfuscate, not illuminate, the complex issues arising from the use of biased so-called "standardized" tests to rank and sort schools and children. By using terms out of the corporate world — "underperforming" stocks, for example, should probably be dumped from your "portfoliio" — Duncan evades reality, rather than illuminates it. And that's how Chicago's corporate school reform wants it. "The administration wants to spend $5 billion to facilitate school turnarounds," the AP article went on. "[This] could translate to $1 billion for every school that is closed and reopened. Much of the money is already approved: The federal school turnaround program gets about $500 million a year, and the stimulus legislation boosted funding to $3.5 billion."
Among other things, Arne Duncan refuses to say how any district will know how to proclaim "underperformance." Just as it proved impossible in Chicago, so it will be across the USA.
But behind the rhetorical smokescreen typical of corporate Chicago's school reform jargon, Duncan is wielding the biggest stick in the history of American public education: the second wave of federal "stimulus" money. The Obama administration intends to force the entire country to begin the massive privatization of public education or face the loss of hundreds of millions of dollars in federal money.
Of course, the feds won't be forcing any policy on anyone: "The various school districts themselves would have to actually order schools closed," the AP article concluded. �
George Schmidt is a longtime Chicago organizer and activist on education issues who taught in that city's public schools for 26 years. As a former candidate for presidency of Chicago's 28,000 member teacher union he received 40% of the vote. He is a founder of Substance News, an invaluable resource for parents and educators.
Share this

Comments

there are no failing schools

there are no failing schools but failing parents and failing upbringing!!!

best identity theft service

Ed hardy clothing

Ed Hardy Online Shop offering Ed hardy clothing to you vintage tattoo inspired fashion and lifestyle for men, women, and children. And we offer many kinds of brand Fashion Coach handbags,Rolex watches,Replica handbags. Welcome to my website,we can offer best 24/7 service.

Replica handbags

Best replica shop online is proud Replica handbags, such as Replica shoes,Replica Gucci,Replica Chanel,Replica Louis Vuitton from our Replica handbags store.Our Replica handbags Catalog is packed with the dream replica handbags you deserve in www.lv138.com. Fashion Fake handbags and other designer Replica handbags wholesale. As the handbags become a standard part of most people's wardrobe.

thats true..............there

thats true..............there are no failing schools but failing parents and failing upbringing.thanks a lot for the sharing
 
<a href="http://customeridentitytheft.com">customer identity theft</a>

it would be a really unwise

it would be a really unwise initiative. . . Paphos in Cyprus

 

every single country in the

every single country in the world is trying to educate their people and obama is doing the opposite despite being the richest country . . .

face acne treatment

The humbleness-in-posts tip

The humbleness-in-posts tip is a good one. Unless your readers have PhDs or other letters (besides RIP) after their name, they wouldn’t add anything new to the post save for some praises which again might not elicit some good comments from other readers.
Watch Movies Online

He has NEVER been in a

He has NEVER been in a classroom as a teacher, a sub or even a TA (teacher assistant).  How the Hell does that happen???  Oh I forgot this is the Milton Friedman Chicago School of Education (one of the Chicago Boys).  As the article clearly states African American/Hispanic folks will see schools in their communities CLOSED!!!
Marriage Counselors
 

This gets harder as your blog

This gets harder as your blog grows but it’s particularly important in the early days of your blog as it shows your readers that their comments are valued, it creates a culture of interactivity and gives the impression to other readers that your comments section is an active place that you as the blogger value.
strategy games

What Is Right And What Is Wrong

When it come to politic agenda there is no such thing as right or wrong .... all depend on the political benefits behind the politician --- acai berry diet benefits ---

We want them to look at their

We want them to look at their students as products, and that the way they can tell whether their product is good is whether its scores are higher, and then they’ll get paid more money.
cheap car insurance comparison

President Barack Obama's

President Barack Obama's Secretary of Education, former Chicago schools Chief Executive Officer Arne Duncan, launched a national campaign in May 2009 to privatize between five and ten percent of the remaining public schools in the USA.
Watch Movies Online

It always comes back to testing

In the end, these complex issues always come back to standarized testing - and what is fair?  When is a school failing?  What about just underperforming?  Politicans always point to some standardized test to support their point of view. 
Look if the Chicago schools are really terrible - close them down.  If this is just political - let's put the kids first for a change.
Thanks.
Susan Acai
 

The point of considering

The point of considering other effects of TV is at least twofold: we might understand something of the mechanisms and conditions for causality by studying clear cases; and it gives a comparison which would allow a much more confident interpretation of null effects in other cases.
 

best credit protection services

Many of you have heard me say

Many of you have heard me say that I believe education is the civil rights issue of our time. I absolutely believe every child is entitled to a high-quality education.
best identity protection

The goal is privatization and

The goal is privatization and ruining the public school system. NYC's mayoral control could make it easier. I consider the article a warning. tvi express

And I think we have under—a

And I think we have under—a corrupt educational system, not in the sense, really, that so many people are making money off it—too many are—but mostly in the sense that we’ve corrupted the purposes.

Acai

In his speech, the president

In his speech, the president said that much of work he is trying to undertake, such as ridding the world of nuclear weapons, is unlikely to be completed before he leaves office.

credit protection

They started adding comments

They started adding comments on our youtube videos, and I know many people are talking among themselves, expressing disappointment in whispered tones with the direction so far of the Obama Administration.

prepaid legal identity theft

Just as it proved impossible

Just as it proved impossible in Chicago, so it will be across the USA.

credit protection reviews

Obama doesn't have authority

Obama doesn't have authority to close and reopen schools himself. That power rests with local school districts and states. But he has an incentive in the economic stimulus law, which requires states to help failing schools improve.
Duncan said that might mean firing an entire staff and bringing in a new one, replacing a principal or turning a school over to a charter school operator. The point, he said, is to take bold action in persistently low-achieving schools.
"Our students have one chance — one chance — to get a quality education," Duncan said in a speech Monday to the Brookings Institution think tank.
"If we turn around just the bottom 1 percent, the bottom thousand schools per year for the next five years, we could really move the needle, lift the bottom and change the lives of tens of millions of underserved children,"
 
 
free classified ads

Chief Educational Overseer

Thanks Mr. Schmidt the article on the Obama’s CEO (Chief Educational Overseer) of Education Arne Duncan.  It looks like America as a whole will now get a full dose of what Chicago Public Schools have already gotten mass mis - education driven by the privatization tycoons and the charter/military school cult.  Using the drill and test charade to fool the public (and that is not very hard to do these days) children will be dumped into high stakes testing meat grinder.  There are two predictable outcomes.  ONE, children that can not endure the test till you drop on slat will more than likely drop out of school.  Even those children with poor attendance will be dropped from school rosters and refused readmission (they call it removing dead weight, whatever happened to trying to keep children IN SCHOOL!!!).  Ether way those academic causalities will more than likely end up involved in some kind of activity which will bring them in contact with the criminal justice system (Welcome to the PRISON INDUSTRIAL BLACK HOLE) AKA the school to prison pipeline.  TWO if you do make it through this testing gauntlet and the military dogma of the charter/military school cult you will end up in some dead end low paying job because there are NOT going to be any high paying jobs (they are leaving the country as faster than cigarette smoke can disappear in a hurricane).  A college education will be ABSOLUTELY out of the question (TOO EXPENSIVE even if you have the grades).  More than likely you will end up in the military fighting and dying somewhere in the world for the endless war on terror (WELCOME TO THE MILITARY INDUSTRIAL BLACK HOLE).
 
 
What is so amazing to me is that someone like Arne Duncan (with NO EXPERIENCE IN EDUCATION WHAT SO EVER) can be the CEO (they used to be called superintendent) of CPS and now the head of the Dept of Education at the national level.  He has NEVER been in a classroom as a teacher, a sub or even a TA (teacher assistant).  How the Hell does that happen???  Oh I forgot this is the Milton Friedman Chicago School of Education (one of the Chicago Boys).  As the article clearly states African American/Hispanic folks will see schools in their communities CLOSED!!!  I bet you MONEY you will not see any close in any WHITE communities!!!  Some of these same schools will reopen as Brand Spanking NEW charter/military schools which will steer children down one of the two paths previously mentioned.
 
 
If Americans (I mean ALL Americans) can not see this as BULLSH*T then we are in DEEP DEEP DOO DOO!!!  We are not talking about things (boxes cups etc) we are talking about REAL human beings and their academic growth and development as human beings IE the FUTURE of AMERICA.  If people, especially Black folks can not see this (blinded by ignorance) or will not see this (too much Obama Kool Aide) as an ASS BACKWARDS deal then we have no one to blame but ourselves.  I think Carter G. Woodson (Mis Education of the Negro) said it best “there are two educations that you get. One is given to you and the other you give yourself.”  It is way past time for us to take a hint get a clue and check a grip come to grips and get a grip so we can S.O.S (Save Our Selves).
 
 
Here are some links that will give more information about the Obama/Duncan Dumb Down Crew.
 
http://www.gregpalast.com/update-obama-slam-duncans-education/#more-2174
 
http://www.blackcommentator.com/310/310_st_black_public_education_printer_friendly.html
 
http://www.blackagendareport.com/?q=content/did-barack-obama-just-appoint-underqualified-stooge-and-privatizer-secretary-education
 
 
Peace
 
 
S Murph
 

When indidulals and Co.'s Profit, it isn't Public interests...

 

The below is taken from an DN Interview in May and i think it sheds great light on this isuue
from another person who Knows.
 
Deborah Meier, Spent nearly four decades working in public education as a teacher, principal, writer and public advocate. She is widely considered to be the founder of the small schools movement and founded a number of public elementary and secondary schools in New York and Boston that serve predominantly low-income African American and Latino students. She won a MacArthur Genius Award in 1987 and is the author of many books, including The Power of Their Ideas, In Schools We Trust and Many Children Left Behind. She serves as principal emeritus of Mission Hill School in Boston, co-chair of the Coalition for Essential Schools, and is currently a senior scholar at NYU’s Steinhardt School of Education.

AMY GOODMAN: We switch gears now to education here at home. Juan?
JUAN GONZALEZ: Well, Education Secretary Arne Duncan outlined the key components of President Obama’s education plan on Capitol Hill Wednesday. Expanding on the White House goal of turning around 5,000 of the lowest-performing public schools in the country over the next five years, Secretary Duncan pledged some $5 billion to improve public schools over the next year. He urged states to take “bold actions” to turn around what he called “dropout factories,” and to consider partnerships with successful charter school operators.

    ARNE DUNCAN: [I’d like to set a goal] to turn around over time 1,000 low-performing schools each year. I do not want to invest in the status quo. For children, families and communities that have been poorly served for too long, we must act with a sense of urgency. We cannot wait, because they cannot wait.
    We think about only 2,000 schools in this country, producing 50 percent of our nation’s dropouts and 75 percent of our minority children dropouts, we have a real challenge there. And we have a real opportunity, with resources on the table and with courage and political will, to challenge that, to work with those dropout factories, to work with their feeder middle schools and elementary schools to fundamentally stop those dropout factories, those dropout pipelines, and do something dramatically better for those children in communities that, I would argue, in many places have been underserved, not for a couple years, but for decades.
    And everyone in this room knows that when children drop out today, they are basically condemned to poverty and to social failure. There are no good jobs out there for a high school dropout. And we have to act now to make sure we do something better for those children in those communities.
    I want states and districts to take bold action that will lead directly to the improvement in student learning. I want local leaders to find those change agents who can fix these schools. I want them to provide incentives for the best teachers and the best principals to take on the challenge of teaching in these schools. And where appropriate, I want them to create partnerships with charter school operators with a track record for success. I want superintendents to be aggressive in taking the difficult step of shutting down a failing school and replacing it with one they know will work. We’ve proposed a $52 million increase in funding to develop and expand successful charter schools.
    Many of you have heard me say that I believe education is the civil rights issue of our time. I absolutely believe every child is entitled to a high-quality education.

AMY GOODMAN: Secretary of Education Arne Duncan, speaking before the House Education and Labor Committee Wednesday.
Well, our next guest is deeply familiar with the state of our educational system, its failings and successes, and the promises and pitfalls of charter schools. Deborah Meier has been—well, has spent nearly four decades working in public education as a teacher, a principal, a writer, a public advocate, considered to be the founder of the small schools movement and founded a number of public elementary and secondary schools here in New York, also in Boston, that serve predominantly low-income African American and Latino students.
Deborah Meier won a MacArthur Genius Award in 1987. She’s the author of many books, including The Power of Their Ideas, In Schools We Trust and Many Children Left Behind.
She serves as principal emeritus of Mission Hill School in Boston, co-chair of the Coalition for Essential Schools, currently senior scholar at NYU’s Steinhardt School of Education.
Welcome to Democracy Now! What is your response to the education policy of President Obama and Arne Duncan, the Education Secretary?
DEBORAH MEIER: I think it’s missing the heart of what’s the problem and looking at this from the eyes of—there’s a wonderful book called Seeing Like a State, which I urge people to read, because there’s a way of looking at what’s wrong with schools that I think the business eye sees, which is different than the teacher, child and parent eye, what’s wrong with our schools. And so, to look for the answer increasingly in distant from where the action takes place, the cutting out of teachers’, parents’ and children’s voices in making decisions about schools, as we escalate the penalties if they don’t meet test scores. The incredible obsession with test scores, particularly in two particular areas, that hardly define what it means to be a well-educated person.
I had a grandmother who probably couldn’t have passed them, but she was a well-educated woman. She had a mindfulness and thoughtfulness about the world around her. She knew how to read the world. And an enormous number of our children are not being educated to have that view of themselves.
So, the focus he has on that, if they don’t graduate high school, that they won’t get as good a job, you know, we have simply upped the scale. We have lots of people who have BAs and MAs who are not making decent wages. General Motors and Chrysler are planning to close plants and send workers overseas, who are less well-educated than the workers who are in those plants now.
So, what disturbs me—and I was just thinking about that program right before this, and I think, oh, who can possibly care about schools when you see what’s happening in some places in the world? But there is a connection. And it’s the lack of good education about the world, my fellow citizens, that contributes to bad politics in America and a democracy that doesn’t come close to meeting its potential. And that’s the connection that I would love our Department of Education to be the bully pulpit on.
JUAN GONZALEZ: Deborah Meiers, I’d like to ask you—obviously the Obama administration and Secretary Duncan are very much behind the idea of more charter schools that are spreading across the country. And actually, you started the small schools movement, that was tremendously successful. What is the essential difference between the small schools movement that you started and these charter schools, where many African American religious leaders and others around the country are buying into and participating in this whole charter school movement?
DEBORAH MEIER: Well, when the charter movement started, while I thought they could have done the same thing within the regular public schools, you know, there were several hundred small schools in New York that grew out of the ’70s, ’80s and early ’90s, and they didn’t get anything like the hype that the charter movement has gotten. And I originally thought it was just another way for small schools to start.
But there’s nothing particular about charter schools that gives schools either greater autonomy to make decisions, powerful decisions, close to the children—that’s what I think is wonderful about a small school, that you can know kids and their families, can all know each other well, and can have a conversation that impacts on the school.
But what we’re seeing instead is an enormous number of pilot schools that are really replicas of the worst parts of the public system, where decisions are made farther and farther away from children, and they’re made on the basis of people who don’t know the kids or that school well. So I pictured a lot of mom and pop stores. And there are some wonderful pilot—charter schools that I love around the country. But 90 percent of what the charter schools have become is not small schools, but just alternate private systems within the public sector.
JUAN GONZALEZ: Well, you have, for instance, chains that are developing—
DEBORAH MEIER: That’s what I mean.
JUAN GONZALEZ: —like the KIPP Academy and some of these others. But one of the things I’ve been noticing in my investigations is that a lot of these charter schools, especially the chain types, pay enormous salaries. I reported on one here in Harlem, Eva Moskowitz. She was making, for just running a school of 300 kids, making $370,000 a year. And the New York Post, last week, reported that a charter school in Brooklyn, the director, was making $700,000 a year. This is a non-profit.
DEBORAH MEIER: And I was making seventy. So, it is an idea cooked up. It was an idea that may have had marvelous origins. I’m really not sure how it started. We have something in Boston called pilot schools, that were an internal attempt to capture the best qualities of charters but to remain within the system and was supported and initiated by the union.
So, what’s interesting to me is the lack of interest in our taking what we’ve learned and using it in the ordinary public system, rather than getting into this blame teacher, blame union fight and pulling schools out of the public sector. And there just isn’t any evidence. None of the studies. Here are these people who are big on test score data, but they are only interested in test score data when they can use it to attack normal public education, because there’s no—there is no consistent evidence that charter schools are getting better results, and there’s no consistent evidence that you can turn around 5,000 schools.
You know, it’s not only that we shouldn’t be driven by data, but informed by data, which would require a much different kind of press coverage of education than we get, so that—we imagine that you can run schools on the basis of a distant—a lever from some distant place that looks at data and manipulates the system from that place. And there’s no data that works. There’s no suggestion—there’s not even, on their own terms, data that works.
The mayor claims that mayoral control works, but, in fact, if you look at the data about which systems are doing best around this country, urban systems, in fact it’s the ones that don’t have mayoral control, not mayoral control. And even in this last round of test scores in New York City, in fact, the cities in New York State that don’t have mayoral control did better than New York City. So, what’s frustrating to me is I don’t like that definition of success, but that they don’t even believe it for themselves.
AMY GOODMAN: Deborah Meier, this past week is the fifty-fifth anniversary of the Brown v. Board of Education decision to desegregate the schools of this country. Where are we today with this?
DEBORAH MEIER: We’re not [inaudible]—not anywhere. I mean, when I came to New York City in the mid-’60s and taught in Central Harlem—actually, by the way, it’s closer to five decades that I’ve been working in the public schools. But when I came to New York City and worked in Central Harlem in kindergarten and was telling the kids about desegregation, it was hard to convince them, because they looked around the room, and what did I—when I said, “It’s only in the South that we have segregation.”
So, segregation has been with us a very long time, but it hasn’t changed. And you can send your kid, if you’re an upper-middle-class New Yorker, you can send your kids, for example, to schools in New York City from kindergarten through twelfth grade that have fewer black and Latino kids in it than most private schools. I know this personally.
And we have not—we’re so interested in the best and the brightest, by our very narrow definition of what we’re looking for in this country, what we mean by merit and what we mean by leadership. So I’m also just stunned by the Department of Education that includes virtually no educators, whose definition of being well-educated is that you graduated from Harvard.
There’s something basically missing about what we want from our schools. And if we don’t get that right, and even discuss it, so that the only meaning of achievement now is improving test scores.
JUAN GONZALEZ: Well, and when you mentioned the people who are running the system that aren’t even educators, increasingly now, especially with this charter school movement, even the principals have no experience as teachers.
DEBORAH MEIER: There is no respect for—now, it’s not the only place we do this. I‘m a little stunned that you send in people on the basis of some general brightness category to fix automobile industries, who know nothing about manufacturing and industry. We’ve gotten—you know, this decade of interest in finance has made us think that only people who know how to manipulate money know how to change the world for the better.
And I think that’s unfortunately the lesson we’re teaching in schools, by the way we view the schools and by the way we want teachers to view their students. We want them to look at their students as products, and that the way they can tell whether their product is good is whether its scores are higher, and then they’ll get paid more money.
And that whole bonus assumption corrupts the work itself. You know, there’s a principle, Campbell’s Principle, I think it’s called, that the more you focus on a particular indicator, the more corrupt that indicator becomes itself. And I think we have under—a corrupt educational system, not in the sense, really, that so many people are making money off it—too many are—but mostly in the sense that we’ve corrupted the purposes.
JUAN GONZALEZ: Well, in New York City, they took it one step further, starting to offer children money for getting higher test scores, right? The mayor wants—has a plan to cash bonuses for students who get higher test scores.
DEBORAH MEIER: Yeah, it’s a fundamental corruption of the definition that I have of being well-educated. And the purpose of small schools and the purpose of a strong and powerful faculty was because you can’t pass on to kids what it means to be part of a powerful community if you’re not part of a powerful community. And teachers whom we don’t respect enough to make judgments of importance can’t teach the fundamental underlying principle of democracy, which is the exercise of judgment.
AMY GOODMAN: Well, we certainly will continue this conversation. We thank you, Deborah Meier, for being on with us today. And I want to encourage teachers and students around the country to suggest stories to us about what’s happening in your community. You can email us at stories@democracynow.org.

 

Charter Schools Are _Public_ Schools

Charter schools are _public_ schools. The public charter school my children go to is the best school in district, it is governed by the parents of the children who attend the school, and most of the innovations that have been introduced at our school have been adopted by all the other schools in the district. The competition of ideas in our District has made all of our public schools better.

...sort of like the federal reserve bank is federal? or a bank?

That's just plain silly.  Or disengenuous.  Or dishonest.  All the pro charter school sites say that charter schools "are public schools" freed from some of the "burdensome restrictions on innovation" that hobble "other" public schools.  In fact, charter schools are public schools like the federal reserve bank is federal or a bank.  Not at all.  They just get public money.  So do Wells Fargo and Citibank.  Does that make them "public banks?
Charter schools can be owned and operated by or as profit making institutions, and thousands of them are operated exactly this way.  The public can access the books, the salary information and program budgets of real public schools, but not of charter schools.  Real public schools cannot turn away students, but charter schools are often based upon the ability to turn students they find inconvenient or not in conformity with their "educational" models.
 

Very aggravating. Watch out NYC

(Disappeared my  whole comment in looking up spelling)
NYC has a billionaire business mayor, and a chancellor,
neither of whom know anything about education.  (Klein
had to get a waiver to get the job.)  I only recently
learned that school principals in the public schools are
often without education backgrounds.  All business,
all the time.
 
Greg Palast had articles when Arne Duncan was being
considered for the job, and Joel Klein was spoken
about as another possible bad choice. 
 
Charter schools are OK, in a limited, very limited
circumstance.  (I had a relative who switched from a
special school for gifted to a small school that was a
charter school over two decades ago.)
 
The goal is privatization and ruining the public school
system.  NYC's mayoral control could make it easier.
I consider the article a warning. 
 
 Addenda: Basir Mchawi had a show on Mayoral control
on his show last night, June 4, 2009, "Education at the Crossroads"
on WBAI.  It will be archived, free, for 90 days, the first in a
series of 3, if all goes well.  www.wbai.org   Guests
included Sam Anderson.
Since there is a "gag" rule at WBAI, to hear views
about what is going on at the community radio station,
go to www.takebackwbai.org   There is video of Basir
Mchawi and Bernard White, fired Program Director on
the matters, as well as other video. 
Also visit www.wbixradio.org 
and www.wbaix.org  WBAI in Exile