BAR brown on white masthead page top
 masthead brown on white

HOLIDAY ISSUE
Dec.20 - Jan. 2

LATEST BLACK AGENDA RADIO!
Click here to listen to Fast Track For Black Yes-Men by Glen Ford
Click here to listen to Barack Obama VS the Legacy of Charles Hamilton Houston by Bruce Dixon

Home Black Agenda Radio Archives & Past Issues Features
About Us New! Black Agenda Blog Links & Resources
 

In 1972, 1,200 stepped up to speak & act purposefully and independently as the Coalition of Black Trade Unionists. BAR and Black Agenda Radio are proud partners of the CBTU.
WWW.CBTU.ORG

Media Reform Conference graphic  
BLACK AGENDA REPORT
will be at the National Conference for Media Reform this January in Memphis.

Don't want to miss another issue of Black Agenda Report?
To be notified when we publish new issues each week, put your email address into the box below and click "Notify me!"


THIS COULD HAVE BEEN YOUR AD
Each week Black Agenda Report reaches an audience that includes thousands of opinion leaders in black America and beyond.
email publisher (at) blackagendareport.com for details.
Black Agenda Radio Ad

The Sit-in Movement was Not Spontaneous: It Took Brains, Sweat, Planning and Organization

by Rhone Fraser

The sit-in movement was built upon deep layers of African American organizational experience stretching back generations.”

The American civil rights narrative has too often been reduced to a tale of spontaneous invention, rather than the product of intense debate, meticulous planning and, often, tactical and strategic genius on the part of the organizers. It’s long past time to tell the truth about this watershed moment in the Black radical tradition.

The sit-ins at public accommodations between 1957 and 1960 ushered in a critical period in U.S. history. In this form of social protest, people literally sat down at racially segregated facilities such as a lunch counters to force the public and politicians to confront the issue of desegregation.

Sit-ins became the cornerstone of evolving civil rights activity. Occurring in clusters in the late 1950s, the early sit-ins culminated in a larger, more deliberate sit-in movement that seized national attention at a Greensboro, North Carolina lunch counter on February 1, 1960. However, the full-blown, post-Greensboro wave of sit-ins could not have been so strikingly successful had it not been for organizational experience garnered during the protests of the late Fifties. Sociologist Aldon Morris writes that by1960:

[S]tudents and seasoned activists were able to rapidly coordinate the sit-ins because both were anchored to the same organization. This vast internal organization consisted of local movement centers, experienced activists who had amassed organizing skills, direct-action organizations, communication systems between centers, pre-existing strategies for dealing with the opposition, workshops and training procedures, fund raising techniques, and community mobilization techniques.”

This challenges previous scholarship about the sit-ins by Howard Zinn who wrote that in this period, “spontaneity and self-sufficiency were the hallmarks of the sit-ins; without adult advice or consent, the students planned and carried them through.” However, the perception that sit-ins occurred without adult advice is simply not supported by the historical record, and needs correction.

This article continues below the brown box.
Black Agenda Report needs $30K to survive through the spring.
Give. Now. Your help is needed and appreciated. PayPal makes it safe and easy to support independent, non-corporate media.
Help us stay out here.
It's that simple
If we don't support our own independent voices, who will?

The post-Greensboro wave of sit-ins could not have been so strikingly successful had it not been for organizational experience garnered during the protests of the late Fifties.”

Aldon Morris says other viewpoints on the sit-in movement, from August Meier, Elliot Rudwick, Louis Lomax and others have “have persistently portrayed pre-existing organization as an after-the-fact accretion on student spontaneity. The dominant view is that SCLC, CORE, NAACP, and community leaders rushed into a dynamic campus movement after it was well underway.” Morris argues the opposite: that the pre-existing organizations of the late 1950s provided the sit-ins with the resources and communication networks needed for their emergence and development. Between February 1st and March 30th of 1960, major sit-in demonstrations and related activity had been conducted in at least sixty-nine Southern cities.

The very rapid spread of sit-ins in 1960 was due to the pre-existing organizational structures of the late 1950s. Spontaneous decisions had very little to do with the growing phenomenon, which was in fact a carefully planned, systematic attack on racial segregation. The 1960 Greensboro sit-in marked the apex of the civil rights movement, after which time people who conducted sit-ins did so with a greater knowledge of mutual support than those before February 1st.

An examination of two sit-in leaders whose activism was effective both before and after February 1st illustrates the influence of the pre-existing organizational support that eventually led to the toppling of Jim Crow. I chose to focus on Ronald Walters and James Lawson because of their unique work in making sit-ins so effective. Ronald Walters, now a Professor of Political Science at the University of Maryland, College Park, established the model of the lunch counter sit-in, while James Lawson, a civil rights icon who is now a Distinguished Visiting Professor at Vanderbilt University, perfected this model. Both men’s goals were to ensure the full and complete integration of the segregated lunch counter. Both activists contribute significantly to the black radical tradition before and after the first of February, 1960 in ways that disprove the notion that student sit-ins were “spontaneous.”

The very rapid spread of sit-ins was the result of a carefully planned, systematic attack on racial segregation.”

In 1958, then twenty-year-old NAACP Youth Council member Ronald Walters began sit-ins at the F.W. Woolworth’s drugstore in downtown Wichita, Kansas. Aldon Morris writes that Walters knew Clara Luper, an NAACP Youth Council leader in Oklahoma City, who organized her own sit-ins in less than a week after Walters’ sit-in in her town. Working through CORE and the local NAACP Youth Council, Clara Luper’s personal friend, Mrs. Shirley Scaggins, organized another group of sit-ins in nearby Tulsa. The first sit-in cluster began in Oklahoma and then spread to cities within a hundred mile radius via established organizational and personal networks. Walters writes that the sit-ins in Oklahoma City were followed by protest demonstrations in the Midwest such as one in St. Louis that began on February 14th, 1959, initiated by the NAACP Youth group led by William Clay, who went on to become a U.S. Congressman. Arguably, Ronald Walters started the chain of lunch counter sit-ins that spread from Wichita, Kansas, to Oklahoma City, to Tulsa, then to St. Louis within a few months. This chain of actions undoubtedly led to the pre-existing organization that triggered the huge wave of sit-ins after the Greensboro protest of February, 1960.

In Nashville, Tennessee, in 1958 James Lawson and other Nashville clergy began conducting what were called “nonviolent workshops” – classes in which Lawson taught local college students the philosophy and tactics of nonviolence protest. Many of the students in Lawson’s workshops would become future officers of the main organization at the vanguard of the sit-in movement: the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC). Lawson’s mentoring of such future SNCC leaders as John Lewis (now a U.S. Congressman) and Diane Nash was an important part of his contribution to radical activism both before and after February 1st, 1960. Journalist David Halberstam writes that Nashville mayor Ben West’s decision to finally integrate the lunch counters came from a direct dialogue with one of Lawson’s students, Diane Nash:

Now standing on the top of the courthouse steps, facing the mayor, she [Nash] who had once been so afraid of confrontation…could look at Ben West and see how vulnerable he was. What she said next, she later noted, came to her like a divine inspiration. Or if not divine inspiration, at least a remembrance of what Jim Lawson had taught them, that they had to get people…to see one another as human beings instead of enemies. So she asked Ben West to use the prestige of his office to end racial segregation...’Yes,’ he found himself saying…They had won, she was sure. The next day’s Tennessean banner headline said it all: INTEGRATE COUNTERS – MAYOR.”

The February – May, 1960 Nashville sit-ins and scores of others that year are often described as “inspired” by the Greensboro protests that also began in February. In fact, 1960 marked an escalation of a civil rights offensive that had begun carefully mapping its way in the Fifties. The sit-in movement was, in turn, built upon deep layers of African American organizational experience stretching back generations.

Black folks did not simply clap and sway their way into winning strategies to defeat Jim Crow.”

Thus, even this brief snapshot of the pre- and post-1960 sit-ins, and a few of the individuals involved, puts the lie to the common, essentially racist assumption that Black folks of the period acted on impulse rather than forethought; that they somehow clapped and swayed their way into the winning strategies that brought down the fortresses of Jim Crow. Nothing could be further from the truth.

The two notables who are the focus of the study in which I am currently immersed – Ronald Walters and James Lawson – are important personages whose activism spans several distinct periods of the modern Black Freedom Struggle, and remain prodigiously active to this day. Their protégés, and those who were mentored and inspired by others, proceeded to change the world – and were themselves transformed in the process.

Spontaneity had very little to do with it.

The author would like to dedicate this article to a devoted nonviolent minister in the true Christian sense, Christopher Staniel Simmons, 1979-2006. 

printer friendly

Rhone Fraser is an independent journalist who writes and produces for Pacifica WBAI radio's Arts Magazine Program.  A graduate student, he is completing a study of the sit-in movement. Fraser recently wrote a documentary play on the life of civil rights activist Fannie Lou Hamer and can be reached at rhone2001@hotmail.com.

CLICK HERE TO COMMENT ON OR DISCUSS THIS ARTICLE ON THE BLACK AGENDA BLOG

WE NEED YOUR SUPPORT AND WE NEED IT NOW,
to last into next year.  Black Agenda Report lives or dies by your donations.

LISTEN TO THE LATEST BLACK AGENDA RADIO COMMENTARIES
November 29, 2006
"You can't stay in a country where 60% of the people want you dead."
CLICK HERE TO LISTEN TO
End Game For the Americans In Iraq
by Glen Ford
November 29, 2006
"You can't stay in a country where 60% of the people want you dead."
CLICK HERE TO LISTEN TO
End Game For the Americans In Iraq
by GLEN FORD
November 22, 2006
"Even the whiff of a military conscription would shatter American public support for US aggressions abroad.
CLICK HERE TO LISTEN
to A Draft Would Cripple US War Plans
by Glen Ford

November 15, 2006
The King monument in DC will cost $200 million.
But America spends next to nothing on solving the problems of poverty and want that defined his legacy.
CLICK HERE TO LISTEN TO
Millions on Monuments, Pennies on People
by GLEN FORD
November 15, 2006
The HBO documentary "Hacking Democracy reveals that voting machines and the programs that run them can not only ADD votes, but SUBTRACT them too.
CLICK HERE TO LISTEN
to Subtracting the Vote
by BRUCE DIXON
November 8, 2006
What is facism?
What would home-grown American facism look like, and how close is it right now?
CLICK HERE TO LISTEN TO
American Facism
by GLEN FORD
November 8, 2006
The so-called war on terror is a palpable fraud. It is enemy propaganda that leaves us no choice but to vote for the politicians who can scare us the most. This is a contest Democrats cannot win and should not play. And we must not let them.
CLICK HERE TO LISTEN
to Ending the So-Called "War on Terror"
by BRUCE DIXON
November 1, 2006
AMERICAN GENOCIDE

When Columbus invaded America there were more than 15 million native Americans in what is now the U.S. By 1890 there were 300,000, a 97% death rate. Our nation sits on the bones on one of the greatest genocides in human history.
CLICK HERE TO LISTEN TO
THE ALL-AMERICAN GENOCIDE
by GLEN FORD
November 1, 2006
WHERE IS THE BLACK CHURCH ON IRAQ?

African Americans overwhelmingly oppose the war in IRaq, and have done so since its beginning. 650,000 Iraqis are now dead, compared to less than 3,000 Americans, a ratio of 200 to 1. Why then, do we allow black preachers in black churches to pray every Sunday ONLY for the Americans “in harm's way” and not for the other 99% of the dead, who are Iraqis?.
CLICK HERE TO LISTEN
to WHERE IS THE BLACK CHURCH ON IRAQ
by BRUCE DIXON

October 25, 2006
MYTH OF THE MELTING POT

White Americans frequently celebrate the US as a “Melting Pot”. The phrase is actually taken from an early 20th century play that lauds the US as a “melting pot” for it called the “races” of Europe alone, transforming them into what we now call “white” Americans.
CLICK HERE TO LISTEN TO
MYTH OF THE MELTING POT
by GLEN FORD

October 25, 2006
WAR IS THE HEALTH OFTHE STATE

America's leaders need war, like vampires need blood. Even if it's war on a noun.
In fact, in an era where politicians create and exploit fear to stay in power, the so-called “war on terror” is an invaluable political tool, something they cannot do without.
CLICK HERE TO LISTEN
to WAR IS THE HEALTH OF THE STATE
by BRUCE DIXON

New in This Week's Black Agenda Report
12-13-2006
Freedom Rider:  Jimmy Carter and Israeli Apartheid;
by Margaret Kimberley
12-13-2006
Uncle Tom Needs An Update: The Label Has Lost Its Potency
by Victor Alan Pate, Sr.
12-13-2006
Prison Nation: Locking Down The labor Force
by Seth Sandronsky
Previously in Black Agenda Report
11-28-06
Freedom Rider: Black Lovers of White Supremacy by Margaret Kimberley
11-28-06
How Many Votes Were Stolen or Supressed This November? by Bruce Dixon
11-28-06
Israel: The Heart of Darkness by Clinton L. Cox
11-28-06
That N-Word Again by Rev. Irene Monroe
11-28-06
Gangster Capitalism& the Third Maroon War by John Maxwell
Previously in Black Agenda Report
11-22-2006
Freedom Rider -- Torturing White America
by Margaret Kimberley
11-22-2006
Dirty Business As Usual
by William Lucy
11-22-2006
Sistas, Where is Thy Victory?
by Thandisizwe Chimurenga
11-22-2006
Escalating Downward: The Collapse of Urban Public Schooling
by Floyd W. Hayes III Ph.D.
11-15-2006
Freedom Rider -- Last Look at the 2006 Election 
by Margaret Kimberley
11-15-2006
Bruce's Beat:  Reader Email Answered 
by Bruce Dixon
11-15-2006
1,000 Words
 
Harold Ford on Election Day 
11-15-2006
The World Exhales
by John Maxwell
11-15-2006
Justifications For Slavery
by Jacqueline Bacon
11-15-2006
The Myth of Black Womens' Progress
by Tamara K. Nopper
11-08-2006
Freedom Rider -- Media in the Tank for Bush
by Margaret Kimberley
11-08-2006
Electing America's First Black President by Proxy Vote
by Marjorie Fields Harris
11-08-2006
Reggae Music is Not All One Love
by Jasmyne Cannick
Recently in Black Agenda Report
11-01-2006
Let Black Democrats Be Black
 Meet the New Boss
by Glen Ford
11-01-2006
Freedom Rider - How to Steal an Election
by Margaret Kimberley
11-01-2006
CBC Monitor -- Burying Rep. Mel Watt (D. NC)
by Leutisha Stills
11-01-2006
The People of Chicago VS Wal-Mart
by Paul Street
11-01-2006
1,000 Words

Photography by Yvonne King Photography by Yvonne King
from the 40th anniversary celebration of the Black Panther Party
11-01-2006
Teaching Racism: Steeped in Stupid
by Bernestine Singley
11-01-2006
The Niggerization of Palestine
by Jonathan Scott
11-01-2006
Nonviolence or No? Still Time To Decide
by Greg Moses
11-01-2006
Nukes in New Zealand?
by Jonathan David Farley, D.Phil
Looking for Black Agenda Report or items from our authors earlier than November 1, 2006?
You can find these on our Past Issues and Archive pages.